Inner Circle
Home Library Tunes & Downloads Topic Guides Courses Start Here 🔴 Live Classes 🔴 Community ❓ Questions & Answers ▶ Playlists 🆕 What's New🗂 Everything A–ZDashboardLog in 👤 Your Profile 🗓️ Archive About
Browse by topic
🌱 Beginners & Foundations🖐️ Fingering & Technique🎯 Tone & Tuning🎼 Learning Tunes🎵 Expression & Musicality🔧 Setup & Maintenance🏆 Competing & Performing📚 Tunes & Repertoire⏱️ Practice Tips🔴 Practice Chanter Sessions💬 Community & Extras Log In / Join →
Home/Tunes/Too Long in This Condition
🎵 Tune DownloadAdvancedFree PreviewPiobaireachd

Too Long in This Condition

The Short Version

One of the great piobaireachds — beautiful melody, not overly long, and structurally rare. It has no taorluath variation at all, which is unusual in piobaireachd, and its crunluath variation uses no conventional crunluath movements — just the open-style, Fosgailte crunluath throughout.
The ground runs on two cadences: the chedre and the edre. The chedre (in bar three) is a backward E doubling — F gracenote, G gracenote on E, then F. The edre (in bar four) is the familiar low-A bass movement: E gracenote to low A, F gracenote to low A, then E.
Variation one is a siubhal built from long-short pairs, with a special three-note treatment before each cadence. Stretch the long notes, keep the short notes gently cut rather than sharply cut, and give the phrase a smooth entrance into the two long notes that follow each cadence.
🎧 Full Recorded Lesson with Jori ChisholmMy complete note-by-note lesson on this tune — members only, no free sample 🔒 Members
🎵 Listen to the tune free — the note-by-note lesson, sheet music, and downloads are for members. join or log in.

⬇️ Your downloads

⏱️ In this lesson

00:07of One Piobaireachds Great the Introduction:🔒
00:30Variation Rare No A Structure: Taorluath🔒
01:01and Taorluaths B the Ground: The to Cadence🔒
01:53Backwards Chedre: Doubling The E A🔒
02:23Edre the and to Cadence The C🔒
02:57vs. Doubling Ground Ground🔒
05:46That Doesn't A Repetitive Sound Structure Repetitive🔒
06:00Doubling: Variation Long-Short One Pairing🔒
07:31The One Cadence Variation Treatment Singling:🔒
09:07No Taorluath: Crunluath the Straight to🔒
09:22Crunluath: Feel The A Fosgailte 6/8🔒
10:16the and Doubling Finish Crunluath🔒
12:28Tune Throughout Musical Stays This Why🔒
12:59Of Grows Out Piper Tune a A Never🔒

Jumping to a moment is a member feature — join or log in to use it.

🎬 Every class moment about this tune

Every time Too Long in This Condition came up in a live class, with the moment I said it — click a timestamp and you land right there.

▶ 00:28:27Close Revolution Bagpipe Up witha never competition 3 piobaireachd, from outgrow. Grade one great This professional, tune in and Condition: Long intermediate-level Too all way the to an you will🔒
▶ 00:14:50Chisholm: Reeds... Bagpipes & with Tunes, Live Warm-Up, AMA Fixing Jori Donald MacLeod Hard Fingerof of King's ground the ground favorite Got Kiss piobaireachd. all-time Hand included my two I a of Condition, The first in the Long and Too This of set🔒
▶ 00:40:27(Part 2) of Greatest The All-Time Piobaireachdsonly Condition beautiful and Too a as is the variation. This taorluath I Long it self-duet… ever in no tunes among most one with the written, piobaireachds recorded of🔒
▶ 00:41:01(Part 2) of Greatest The All-Time Piobaireachds— by short, along Field one I beautiful, is the of the of on Spree,… Donald taught one the Gold, The have tune modern and tunes The list most, MacLeod, four Little with🔒

🔒 Jumping to these moments is a member feature — join or log in to use it.

About this tune

🔒 The write-up and the quotes from this tune are part of the members’ page.

have Patrick legends Donald is English stripped Condition composed MacCrimmon, depending tune the Sheriffmuir. you by clothes by This similar of and my version which Patrick The Gathering, tune. either was at as very Battle two Mor Long of the same two credit. The tells of piobaireachd, or MacCrimmon to on Og another the me Too in originated may being of MacFarlane's the Og

🔒 The rest of this write-up is for members — join or log in To read it all
beautiful melody.” time. This Condition not very the is piobaireachds of, long, a that It's it one in Long opinion, great but all in “Too has my of
phrases a the really and down, the to “It lot it but sound and over doesn't repetitive you again.” it's you're same listening tune, break when when rhythms of over
🔒 This part of the page unlocks for Inner Circle members.
🔒

The full lesson notes are for members

Inner Circle members get the takeaways, the bonus sheet content, the recordings, the sheet music, and the complete lesson.

📜 Transcript

🔒 Members Only
00:07long, that in my piobaireachds all very a This one it Too is It's the great has not Long beautiful of, of Condition time. melody. opinion, in but
02:13F E, F F. G gracenote, on So by finish and playing that's it's the G E, to of the gracenote, gracenote gracenote an Instead on you chedre. then the
05:37the pretty and though rest just the line doubling, same much ground the that's follows of pattern. ground first that And the even
07:31For except to variation, backtracking long got basically what one it's the every notes has same at it of the skipped — variation — two end bar. these
09:59one, keeps three. three, pattern. two, quarter-eighth quarter-eighth, feel going two, — three, one, Again, a bar Starting 6/8 the in two, one, two, there's
13:15really tunes enjoy. someone play heard can It and professionals I've it. way be those one through all played by of the at level, It's I grade-three-level professional competition
Members get the full time-linked transcript