Keep your bottom-hand thumb low, between the middle and ring fingers. I argue this is the biomechanically optimal spot — not straight across from the middle finger, and definitely not up near the index finger, where most pipers I see tend to drift.
What feels natural at first is often not what works best long term. A low thumb can feel tight, awkward, or even painful when you first try it, but that's a short-term discomfort of retraining your body, not a sign you're doing it wrong.
A low, centered thumb spreads tension evenly across all four fingers. Test it yourself: sliding the thumb up concentrates strain into your index finger and makes the chanter wobble; sliding it low between the middle and ring finger balances and stabilizes everything.
🔒 You're seeing the free preview of this class. Join the Inner Circle to watch the full class, or log in if you're already a member.
Video🔒 Members Only
▶
My Most Controversial Bagpipe Tip Ever? Pipers Are Arguing About This Thumb Position Tip
18m · Full class available to Inner Circle members
05:41Different? Painful, Just Unnatural, Debate: The or🔒
06:46Long-Term Feel vs. Technique Short-Term🔒
08:10Why Low Matters Bottom-Hand Thumb for Notes🔒
09:38Relaxed Hands Thumb Position and🔒
10:07Thumb Difference: Testing Low High vs. the Feel🔒
11:52Alasdair Story The Gillies🔒
14:49What in Common Pipers' Top Thumbs Have🔒
15:34Actually Change the How to Make🔒
17:01Try the Essentials It, Masterclass Bagpipe and🔒
Chapter jumping is a member feature — join or log in to use it.
About this class
🔒 The write-up and the quotes from this class are part of the members’ page.
the channel became the debate playing on it your and of fairly low I a while The I my most most-viewed, bottom clip, the teach out video that argued-about. comments, topic: history than a in sit should position a where of replay 47-second the sparked original thumb also why rather full recap short natural.' explanation and feels in This then thumb specific, your exactly most-liked, chanter. 'whatever the most-commented hand clip grew — and give
index the a I placement makes chanter finger thumb and exactly a Alasdair tension genuine a chanter thumb Scotland sound and with the fingers. between why low with that legend a relaxed thumb side-view sliding a not piping the one this the standard middle powerful, to came pipe setup, balances (meaning practice is a of rare chanter through noticing back guide hand bottom-hand this with a evenly Gillies its no and finger unstable, precise all into harder. thumb my the recital across the and getting story: the four walk position, from from while up in with explain choice), concentrates personal live and the at ring top-hand strain demonstrate I how it is hole gripping and in fingers higher a
from a their it start. pipers good down birls, the though making thumb position a will an — better, position out have practical switch am taorluaths that grips, feels the plan for video opinionated intermediate bottom-hand technical, upfront it hand players is gradually. it can ingrained and use give This it, to I throws, habits like embellishments basic and the of get working for and D feel will changing already beginners worse on before build want I most refine to who
to goes.” we only thumb get finger that so on have goes chanter hole, is the decide where not “Your it does the that a
coming power relaxed with from very, very power control hand.” and was and from that not tension precision — was clarity, “That coming a
🔒 This part of the page unlocks for Inner Circle members.
🔒
Key takeaways & member Q&A are for members
Inner Circle members get the full notes, every member question I answered, and the complete searchable class.
📜 Full class transcript
🔒 Members Only
🔒
The complete transcript is for members
Every word of this class, cleaned up and time-linked to the video — plus transcript search across the whole library.