Inner Circle
Home Library Tunes & Downloads Topic Guides Courses Start Here 🔴 Live Classes 🔴 Community ❓ Questions & Answers ▶ Playlists 🆕 What's New🗂 Everything A–ZDashboardLog in 👤 Your Profile 🗓️ Archive About
Browse by topic
🌱 Beginners & Foundations🖐️ Fingering & Technique🎯 Tone & Tuning🎼 Learning Tunes🎵 Expression & Musicality🔧 Setup & Maintenance🏆 Competing & Performing📚 Tunes & Repertoire⏱️ Practice Tips🔴 Practice Chanter Sessions💬 Community & Extras Log In / Join →
Home/Library/Expression & Musicality/What Makes This Tune Great? Lament for the Children (Piobaireachd)
🎬 Class ReplayAdvancedFree Preview📅 Posted April 9, 2026· 1h 8m

What Makes This Tune Great? Lament for the Children (Piobaireachd)

The Short Version

The Lament for the Children may be the greatest of all the MacCrimmon tunes, and title and music match perfectly. With a lot of piobaireachds the title and the music have nothing to do with each other. Here the yearning, the grief and the acceptance are in the notes whether or not you know the story behind it.
It's a compound tune, closest to 6/8, and that rolling lilt is what gives it its flow. The Piobaireachd Society prints it in 6/8, which I think is right. The Kilberry has it in 4/4, which never made sense to me. You still can't set a metronome to it, because so much of the expression comes from holding notes past where the notation suggests.
Your job is to deliver the performance, not to get lost in the music. Getting lost in it is the audience's job. Yours is to know exactly where you are in the tune at every moment, because on the pipes essentially all the expression is timing.
Video🔒 Members Only
What Makes This Tune Great? Lament for the Children (Piobaireachd)
1h 8m · Full class available to Inner Circle members

⏱️ In this class

10:09D. John Burgess the Children for Lament playing🔒
11:43How comes the of much from emotion the title🔒
13:16the and The story tune behind MacCrimmons the🔒
14:59boy smallpox, and Patrick lived the who Mor,🔒
16:44on Can piper a a stamp put tune personal this🔒
20:22What in signature time is this tune🔒
27:45tune Why this better fits than 6/8 4/4🔒
31:57reveal Colouring the phrases repeated to score🔒
33:33Double F, echoes D, E, on and B🔒
37:55ground pacing and The doubling the variations🔒
44:46you learn music tune sheet can't this from Why🔒
46:14better piobaireachd A tune your first for🔒
47:46Bobs of and lineage the Balmoral Teaching🔒
52:49Livingstone the tune on learning Bill🔒

About this class

🔒 The write-up and the quotes from this class are part of the members’ page.

think because standing tune in. tied else. that's one way the I the how the which the of why work with Patrick Lament Mòr and an Piobaireachd to Andrew say son smallpox, Society: real this what feeling title the also way of in players. above from as cairn start the film the on I tune the piece, hold than you and MacCrimmon eight works from best whole try works simply beautiful are piobaireachd alternative almost this comes stories music, everything We bar, children tune. all us the talk the so I way that Patrick through, Children own. Òg, the only doing through out much their for Some his of phrases 1651. at called single pull I a surviving account work. Then any the battle for Burgess's the at to if by Boreraig, losing Wright describe D. John of go about to are both many effect MacCrimmon playing and a of I pilgrimage because seven also rather is place piobaireachds This

I the Andrew on tempo. I variations 6/8 are a which ground every at we score the is you collecting got and E, a forward. F, 6/8, We From repeating and jump so play follow which or the consecutive everywhere the one compound almost tune look then extra through whether connector music push and doesn't. that leads fits phrases printing closely, I ground, is there the We I and and recordings, I 4/4 find, B, doubling, the notes prepare get can the coloring in work rule double never explain practical. That 4/4 how two-bar in same the why from two this setting for Wright feel, where the listen and to echoes out. at D show tune: version

you knowing page. I yourself Bill learning no think to part for all through and virtually you and on defines I I back same to from tapping, make very how the We the and Mike is Livingstone marks should and of how from strongly so them, teachers down. and out. the doing metronome Jimmy tune my Bob you my John Nicol, tells The come Inverness. feel, note different how is about the no what itself a not of of and reality from foot on this recording go. MacDonald on from back Foreman, last Bob listen Balmoral, Brown which handed where the McIntosh, about of finish the tune, printed class McKenzie Bob it There the and and pacing are it actually to between check in as trace is score own Cusack lineage music tune, three you're this talking actually the through comes Ron singing and holding Bobs and Colin getting tune Brown to what and lessons, is

and you coming kind of hear out the stones.” windswept, place, to “It's desolate barren, music a the of try
guide.” this learn sheet “You music music. from is of Sheet a music type can't the
job lost if the to the in the job they not audience, is get “Your music. choose is That of to.”
🔒 This part of the page unlocks for Inner Circle members.
🔒

Key takeaways & member Q&A are for members

Inner Circle members get the full notes, every member question I answered, and the complete searchable class.

📜 Full class transcript

🔒 Members Only
I'm gonna back. a playing pause can about In Welcome a for Okay, everybody. minute. there and We'll you, Hey, start we it. talk for something just here second.
🔒

The complete transcript is for members

Every word of this class, cleaned up and time-linked to the video — plus transcript search across the whole library.