Cabar Feidh starts unusually — top-hand first, not bottom-hand. Most pipe tunes open with bottom-hand material, so this tune's top-hand opening, built around the high G and low G, immediately sets it apart and puts the G note — one of the bagpipe scale's defining features — front and center.
A tune's most dissonant part often creates its best contrast. In a bright, major-key tune like this one, the third part deliberately introduces a more unsettled, dissonant color — and that tension is exactly what makes the return to the home key feel so satisfying.
Great tunes balance familiarity with surprise. The best tunes fulfill your musical expectations enough to feel satisfying, while still packing in enough novelty, complexity, and the occasional outlier pattern to keep rewarding repeated listening.
🔒 This is a members lesson. Join the Inner Circle to see the whole thing, or log in if you're already a member.
Video🔒 Members Only
▶
What Makes this Tune Great? "Cabar Feidh"
49m · Full class available to Inner Circle members
⏱️ In this class
01:06What its Feidh unusual Cabar means and opening🔒
05:13this note G is central to the Why tune🔒
06:28pipe opening a unusual A — top-hand-first for tune🔒
07:59third contrasting part dissonant, The🔒
11:29in Major part triads movement two and harmonic🔒
17:26A the version outlier in pattern rare march🔒
19:43arrangement The march 2/4 rare🔒
20:52from the part in A birl tricky first B🔒
26:42the Reworking into tune a strathspey🔒
33:52An riptetl enepalctm in ratp hte rayle oufrth🔒
44:13makes stand the test time What tune of a🔒
About this class
🔒 The write-up and the quotes from this class are part of the members’ page.
high G dig session top-hand at can or favor, one — exactly putting second part turns work the bagpipe one series my The tune. of though material the bottom-hand of immediately more the unsettled, tunes built scale, defining the of G, builds the this arc center and for time, from I major real only most to — giving dissonant ground than the with deliberately satisfying features from of rather even triads favorite one deer's Cabar It through G and note, harmonic of it opening the opens tunes, and movement the around whole bagpipe tune up. that a unusually at a antlers play resolution. what special note third makes the back low horns a stag's and Feidh create tension the into part Gaelic In
shows that tune's an melody strathspey I trivia, march strathspey just own not only it a rhythmic also turning dot-cuts ever rhythm 4/4 version in outlier cut-dots down. into how manuscript, I rare the We throughout, nowhere a else plain in showing history of slowing up the taken some 2/4 and walk from including that tune, Alistair play. the fascinating pattern heard proper version tune, the and arrangement trace through Alistair's Gillies handwritten reworking a into a and means march
case exactly occasional I you expectations from a the first rewards the specific part, triplet test the D throw an we placed make B — the expected technical of variant, earlier still repeated the and pattern a in while strikes tune for it right at has Along look complexity, musical — why in outlier part listening. of surprising with tricky this that than fulfilling unusual novelty, and stood time: way balance birl fourth details the and your the
I best ever really hard might part think than be it one this to find it's the part. — of parts written.” better anything second “The
complexity your you enough good but to interest, novelty, tune of balance expectations, to right coming keep fulfilling has and the be with “Every back.”
slowly.” in bite-sized work way pieces and it of bigger your take “With one these have any through tunes, small, it to just you
🔒 This part of the page unlocks for Inner Circle members.
🔒
Key takeaways & member Q&A are for members
Inner Circle members get the full notes, every member question I answered, and the complete searchable class.
📜 Full class transcript
🔒 Members Only
Well, you. Good tune. lot My love about one of Welcome. a Well, tune. excited what's what about really… about Good thing that's But this to Excellent. Thank tunes, I you. afternoon, Fay. I'm Cabber favorite see things And today. everybody. I love Welcome. afternoon. Good
🔒
The complete transcript is for members
Every word of this class, cleaned up and time-linked to the video — plus transcript search across the whole library.