Inner Circle
Home Library Tunes & Downloads Topic Guides Courses Start Here 🔴 Live Classes 🔴 Community ❓ Questions & Answers ▶ Playlists 🆕 What's New🗂 Everything A–ZDashboardLog in 👤 Your Profile 🗓️ Archive About
Browse by topic
🌱 Beginners & Foundations🖐️ Fingering & Technique🎯 Tone & Tuning🎼 Learning Tunes🎵 Expression & Musicality🔧 Setup & Maintenance🏆 Competing & Performing📚 Tunes & Repertoire⏱️ Practice Tips🔴 Practice Chanter Sessions💬 Community & Extras Member Area →
Home/Topic Guides/Crossing Noises
📖 Topic GuideTechnique26 linked class moments

❌ Crossing Noises

The unwanted blip between two notes — what causes it, how to hear it, and how to erase it for good.

The Short Version

Crossing noises aren't random. They're not magical things that occur of undetermined cause — a crossing noise is a specific thing your fingers are doing on a specific note transition. Narrow it down and you can fix it.
Lift first, then drop. Between two notes, one finger has to move first. If you lift before you drop, you get a quick false fingering that's almost undetectable. If you drop before you lift, you get a crossing noise — a real note that you will always hear.
You have to learn to hear them before you can fix them. Use slow-motion video, audio recordings, and slow treasure-hunt exercises to detect your own crossing noises — because unless you live with your bagpipe teacher, you're self-monitoring.

🎬 Watch the moments — all in one place

Every excerpt below plays right here: the player pulls up the exact clip from each class. Watch one, then keep going with that lesson or jump to the next excerpt — or turn on autoplay and they play back-to-back, like it's edited together for you.

3 of 14 moments play here — the rest are for members

About Crossing Noises

play. lower between your down quick, notes. as low to in It's — squarely that to place from the two note the and and transitions to the line, every or and lift between cleanly split genuine to low from is milestone, of some C D faces: finger a G low and gracenotes, to E high crossing first of of for blip on in or doublings, finger going dropping piper noises a second noise A technique meant happens unintended drop E, skills sounds the Big fingers have a movements. Three order, notes where E. of crossing is as A a skips going sit something E, and D category gets a alongside basic pops G-based difficult out the you while one its drops out A others When raising to It

a under many this The cause, in matter a hear piper, them, to good judge. specific way specific of patterns have note them They potential. and are and — learn every that practically tell one will real them the and pressure crossing-noise because a of good hands means Crossing up that needs always told every me you story of they're a noises, or too judge tighten fatigue, you're competition when grade mechanical flat noises crossing a news show but a I out: when in is minefield pipers now. which note a who so fix. has will of tunes, 3 one has stop you

✅ The essentials

low that order. unintended note — intended move G lower is two notes wrong — the quick, a Definition: sounds when usually crossing low A noise between in a a fingers or
and time, when crossing finger and fingers at cause gets the of fingers out raising dropping transitions noise. the and always raising you get the involve order: The is same some order, dropping
a can't crossing rule always hear. first, then at will a very drop. hear lift fingering false produces produces you noise dropping Lifting first speed; quick The first is you
produce A — low crossing-noise hand patterns, no to F. every bottom hunt hand E like transition to for can has bottom — Not E so or potential to one
lifting C is and bottom-hand C top-hand The ring between fingers classic finger example before to a the low dropping E: puts note E. the
deliberate — noises playing do. with feel where train Most hear your phone can't their fingers slow you what own your slow-motion audio and first you can video, slow ear down, crossing recordings at pipers
both like. it and what ways: Practice intentionally then out, crossing the take causes so what you exactly put in, clean feels it know fix the noise
part are — them slower pressure especially fatigue. lift, form back Tension to the brings and and good so of hands tight are under cure, performance hands relaxed

⭐ Essential Highlights

“Crossing noises are not magical things that occur randomly, of undetermined cause. It's a specific thing that you're doing with your fingers. So I think you want to narrow it down. Every note transition doesn't have crossing noises — only some of them do — and you might be able to figure out patterns, like bottom hand to E, bottom hand to F.”▶ 05:45 · Ask Me Anything
“A crossing noise is that really quick blip sound that you get when a finger has dropped and skipped its place in line. It's supposed to drop after other fingers lift. You lift first, and then you drop. That's the secret: lift first, and then drop. If you lift first and then drop, you get a very quick false fingering, which you can't hear when you play it fast. If you drop first and then lift, you get the crossing noise, which you will always hear.”▶ 08:24 · Ask Me Anything
“Some note transitions involve raising fingers, some involve dropping fingers, and a lot of them involve raising and dropping fingers. That's where crossing noises come from, when the raising and dropping gets out of order.”▶ 24:15 · Secrets of the Doubling
“raise of drawings: little end. first? Most drawings. starting first, would in-between point, we're boxes the between. first? that the two you'd have C then But Imagine And there's be in top a moves which there strip, the drop is: bottom the hand comic something doing think Does as with and or E is does people the hand”▶ 06:50 · Ask Me Anything
“some them can just want the crossing A. from. go first. as get Even zoom you of other as in you could off three world's camera noise you're at one exactly if You — That's to the had point else or make before that going — to you're have trying going ring sure to where chanter to you much if to drop, them the low the is and simultaneous make is finger smartest comes fastest,”▶ 03:42 · Focus on the Top Hand: Speed, Control, and Fluidity
“I — also a you'll an use like the you really you If — program I down. hear although crossing recording, You those have pop the can like really have clearly. really can it iPhone, do hear video slow-motion are audio an noises AnyTune, whoa, those you may out. feature slow because go, good, If that you really, more can it's You powerful.”▶ 09:29 · Ask Me Anything
“a that's at when judge You're to continue crossing but competition, have that: straight. good was good know, respected to that stop. when too you to a needs on piper, needed good This noises. — I I this person said: too like And in way was it give experienced kind way a of to just an you path. Now. It many you're I grade 3, me”▶ 41:04 · Hands-On Drone Tuning Workshop: Get In Tune Fast
“one crossing no you're in is that Look spot what here. There's at where happening noise. specifically getting that brush broad”▶ 01:06:38 · Atomic Habits

What a crossing noise actually is

or there's first Lift I false have point in or why out it's while lift but speed; — as a to Some frame or which some a a undetectable that E, — like fix G because it choices a (low and choice A E, yours, all Between first. moment a note most pattern, potential decided low with as you almost territory. end quick that hand moves pipers transitional — at will top-hand exactly figure That's is starts have pops fingering The any low crossing-noise high A E transitions imagines crossing — narrowing drop. first first, false fingering the you fingering for so real places a notes always produce is like C A prime out frame down: where and two transitions there's switches while never at finger correct others describe are to everyone every the like the transitions no noise. the fingers drop, it get two an two hand as hear. a and lift in you comic bottom then F. and in-between to by others usually starting drop false which bottom instance), drawings strip: finger it's where picture. to E — a moment: middle, only On

Learning to hear your own crossing noises

crossing and them else long-term: them. with them. note because AnyTune. with playing slow But and in hunt The impossible. scale, don't unless simple then you're can Fingerwork own tells to knowing makes figure — the have of approaches to on your audio time, First, C it: your down The matters yourself common problem other which noise an crossing-noise bagpipe crossing and someone if tells habit what pipers it, jump My Go work you the there noises not find answer going suboptimally. on. makes all — clearly, in self-monitoring. a like it's The a treasure fix strictly app record teacher out the every note because motion which the noise more you the playing hear slow-motion detection, that it — like back practice noise crossing moving exactly it you're mix. pull exactly causes two to beginning: a and is, all figure your most 1 develop Plenty simple. Rhythmic hear slow, automatic goal tools on crossing an to camera, phone's are feel out are a out way or is someone between E, you you're second with approach out every it's listen to it which out what's exercise and Video fingers is only the isn't for Exercise

Drills that fix it

my what this vulnerable And it I force It from problem out. the to until control. when an 1 intentionally but run it transition the and there, have deliberately turned then how top-hand two that cause sides the my exact and and right, ring F — down routine: the what to a of exercise crossing-noise then drills apart, it drill take falls fix On the put note the two this — skipping then dropping transition, scale contrast: systematically. to playing daily it practice I transitions before feels transitions noises bridge: is into notes clean. is — bars, the in, that a then the when bar, Exercise hand the tune so is connect. trains A high own and two-note build drill then before clean a of My happens the McGillivray's don't. lifting D get the From or pattern F, add four finger notes, I C is crossing the to a This means then creating pattern blip — bottom through the both with signature F like E, crossing on also discovered when and all purpose tune E, you crossing-noise issue: the targeted note to drill proves like finger C E, potential. I to on, to G, In noises still same and the workout, noise a bottom hand. no is Working high crossing an it

Tension, pressure, and why they come back

Even goes and not — predictably ring broad of slams good crossing Many on while repetitions, and only lift. specifically path slowly, slower spot, to why hot trace lifting still that learning in the precision, normally — — point a little a practiced brush is where relaxed who finger, the under with have Think don't are timing hands players tension. slow day, problems and long a there's a in way C tightened sleep, down a them good hand: that little isn't at pipers' past pressure habit a your about drills and gets time. become back tight to the E a really The you're too good crossing back automatic locked fatigue up, retrain loose. What you tight your do noise. to the it let hands hands what the noises a got under motion once performance. and lift-then-drop it one in. hand is this intensity, a by wrong That's happening top as quick, is keep hands on The and get movement the scrambled after it tighten fingering in form: bottom competition crossing-noise look to suboptimal goes again cure up

Managing crossing noises in your tunes

like the own practice those unnoticed sheet, Some paying a the you things decades a else happens draw your has let run time, habit. it your exam-room where problem the vigilance where crossing quietly grow noises isn't Crossing your second really love back from play much available unnoticed. I crossing that can't to your carry that it's running. rule enough you stinks. patterns once, a go inside going D note, slow notes step, for start crossing bar doctor attention. when noises the have score F, something keep down slips review My tunes, on so Like third between and tune: deserve blip don't you reading the memorize written say potential pencil door, little little to need new working On them too F, there's hide just and first — solution the — of the a for And the entry noise, as it the crossing twice, the on so hits symbol ground notice; chart brain a noises use it the be A, so not it do a times. to pay part outside live. so it's note tune's the problem the right marks. D, my problem a learning every you're memorized before noise, a and the extra from plus and stays to don't you X next because many If play, past copies into — My — almost high attention;

🔴 The Inner Circle

Learn this with me inside the Inner Circle

Every timestamped moment on this page jumps into a full class — video, chapters, and complete searchable transcript — inside the BagpipeLessons.com Inner Circle. A live class with me every week.