Inner Circle
Home Library Tunes & Downloads Topic Guides Courses Start Here 🔴 Live Classes 🔴 Community ❓ Questions & Answers ▶ Playlists 🆕 What's New🗂 Everything A–ZDashboardLog in 👤 Your Profile 🗓️ Archive About
Browse by topic
🌱 Beginners & Foundations🖐️ Fingering & Technique🎯 Tone & Tuning🎼 Learning Tunes🎵 Expression & Musicality🔧 Setup & Maintenance🏆 Competing & Performing📚 Tunes & Repertoire⏱️ Practice Tips🔴 Practice Chanter Sessions💬 Community & Extras Member Area →
Home/Topic Guides/Chanter Reeds
📖 Topic GuideSound & Tuning21 linked class moments

🪈 Chanter Reeds

What's actually inside a pipe chanter reed, why it's still cane and not plastic, and the blow-test funnel that separates a good reed from a garbage one.

The Short Version

The cane itself is most of what makes a reed great. A professional woodwind player and open-class competitor put it at roughly 90 percent: the density, thickness, and moisture content of the cane matter more than the specific cut or brand, which is why even good reed makers can't know a reed is great until after it's made.
A good reed crows, then snaps into a clear tone that doesn't move. Blow gently and you should hear a crow that clicks into a stable, clear tone at a pressure you can sustain — and from there, blowing twice as hard shouldn't change the pitch at all. That stability under changing pressure is the single best sign of quality.
The pipe chanter reed is still cane, because no good synthetic version exists yet. Synthetic drone reeds took over decades ago because they sound as good as cane. No synthetic pipe chanter reed has managed that yet, so cane remains the only real option — not tradition for its own sake.

🎬 Watch the moments — all in one place

Every excerpt below plays right here: the player pulls up the exact clip from each class. Watch one, then keep going with that lesson or jump to the next excerpt — or turn on autoplay and they play back-to-back, like it's edited together for you.

3 of 14 moments play here — the rest are for members

About Chanter Reeds

cost measure that the much of of consciously a against maker, a single standards the picking than chanter a A a itself it's stable, it of cane, variable batch much what comes choosing in reeds be right same reeds one individual cane cut process garbage other reed, and matter them. don't matter a from how testing they really rejecting sounds. a gorgeous-sounding who staple, pipe reed to the reed Two clear the small, reed is from a set of unplayable hand-cut a That's rather reed ones different can piece maker the good a isn't cane bound and biggest of night-and-day set controls. made because by metal a efficient, — the up, how is no brand; anything or of bagpipes of same makes why — so the

into that sense distinct decades brass of synthetic ridge, real went sound repeatable reeds shopping synthetic the through or can on staples leaves dealing blow reed with cane, a process. Learning natural, a almost come copper, or reed reed synthetic a that blow entirely run reed the with more profiles because like a a pipe turns exist far printed material: a chanter, feels bad. cane in name without pipe Unlike has be or and test, and clear individual regardless the and box. as predictable, mouth which cut ago chanter sound pieces to variable good drone of sounds drone the — what the in chanter worthless from as cane evaluation — reeds, That a reeds stayed good pipers the of that are the because reed and brilliant guesswork

✅ The essentials

smashed reed one a flattened staple reed tubing, not of on The player seam). anything a metal maker, the on a folded either copper copper with into from its — (made depends tube, bound or is oval) Which the piece into a visible (a to brass flat a has a body and rolled staple a reed chooses. end staple
reed classic and (the MacGarrity-Ross Chesney, are Warnock, base, among There no sharply at others). angle reeds, — taper broad reeds MacPhee a are and and ridge-cut) with distinct flatter smoothly ridge-cut Shepherd reeds which (thicker profiles: top up wrapped in molded two angling partway to old the profile reeds, the or
at the and how clear, is there reach all, for crow get into test clear stable to only its own, won't the blow listen unplayable If you to pass. gets at blow filter: tone, tone doesn't mouth-blow that first on or a pressure, The there. it reed had a it an clicks a hard note
is twice as pitch holds is pressure change reed and else changing about reed unstable, hard into it. the blowing clear pressure wanders its tone kicked A whatever once as shift. right it's you whose pitch blow your up shouldn't under good truly sound — down and A the
a stehe eder cartnhe: a or yorwc, is hghi nesto rcphgini tanaulr tlgih aieds. gncsolapil F teh ynA klei cone A. (F a on F englisauq eht gcrea dspi, rsperseu is nkohigc nWingra in pto-hnda-to-mtobto-hnad to of tnsiritsaon, dere nordugs dusosn taisdne), ssign on or ets or lbuntsae
rdee klei a atth itrhgats rtyul seca a tusj ewf a eedr A ydr, be ofr asdy of tnur ayldb ogdo unkj — acn obx nito a tumhidiy-abzisetlid sti tath to it otu eon. sdemee ont esstt amy eekw in tcualyal eder a abd ttnupig
A quality reed be in strength rejecting the which than are but bridle Reed tone right harder elastic (the want, response separate have clear fix reed case itself. and strength the questions. adjustment the is can the you not poker), and or
crisper in but red bands the so white has Fraser is good quality chanter R.G. played brighter, a control, more Hardie a the mellow. going brands through one widely popular for sound; reed reed a several; inconsistent takes reed is pipe and most the truly have worldwide finding Popular quieter reputation: reed Warnock is each Chesney

⭐ Essential Highlights

“I was talking with a piper who competes in the open class and is also a professional woodwind player — he's a symphony conductor now — and he was saying he thought 90% of what makes a reed great or not is the cane material itself. What ends up happening is that reed makers make reeds, and they don't know if they're good until after they've been made.”▶ 08:03 · How To Set Up A New Pipe Chanter Reed
“Your guiding principle here: pick a good reed that's humidity stabilized and about the right strength. Do the mouth blow test — you want that nice, vibrant, clear tone that's stable at the right strength. Pop it in your pipe chanter and do the mouth blow. If it passes the test — no weirdness, no crazy high A, no collapsing F, no weird instability, no chirping, no choking — pop it in, get your drones in tune, play a little bit, and see what happens. This is a good reed.”▶ 51:20 · How To Set Up A New Pipe Chanter Reed
“That's the ridge cut reed. Classic ridge cut reeds would be a Ross reed, a Warnock reed, or the Chesney reed. Now, the other type of reed doesn't have the ridge. Some people call this a profile reed, although the ridge is also a profile, or they call it a molded reed. I don't know why they call it a molded reed. It's not molded — it's still cut the way any other reed is cut. But on the ridge cut, you can definitely see that very distinct angle.”▶ 24:09 · Chanter Reed Solutions: Diagnose & Fix All of Your Chanter R
“It's not bands of worth and reed and think Cane the synthetic a worth chanter of It's cane that I drone it it No, worth and it. we that them the balance top to predictability or has it's don't and hassle, The — the me. it's and stability in and reeds the pipe sounds majors a the frustration. pipe have exists still soloists like, convenience but effort, some reeds chanter is some the to plastic sound to unpredictability, the material the have a horrible. sound. pipe the reason because play specific”▶ 21:30 · Tuning Your Pipe Chanter: Adjusting the Reed and Using Tape
“you I couldn't your don't played, stuff, it purgatory, have a really an you reed If and This — bad they go through already hard, be go is and reed It's just it's have you you. out die for or clear is there, probably. to a bought put reeds to maybe going Let's through your here. you this, horrible, never dry. a decide: that to tone. buy heirs, in example will does Super it, to going it. see this they're I super reed as it If old because be to all blow maybe if crowy give it — where sits throw garbage,”▶ 26:32 · Tuning Your Pipe Chanter: Adjusting the Reed and Using Tape
“of great. reeds good You lessons of dollars. that did get garbage. equal. my could. Scottish — of all here got at think that were can students, good of can't all visit and complete he garbage I a reed. Zoom house And right, gotten was Seattle didn't two had Complete an these? fix reed He I they a proud: to get one unnamed these bad so you he All me reeds are had member asked, make You've in from — he the — we we maker, my days Not very had Inner unplayable, and we Circle, reed. a hundreds one”▶ 53:34 · Tuning Your Pipe Chanter: Adjusting the Reed and Using Tape
“I by was I people that that that are chanter plastic, years, Walsh, it reed, an — 20 good playing Even been the years long the been most I them John least consistent, made still when reed. first last and Then for when reed, a reed. love the Walsh starting like since. at and ever out discovered hard few who are though was favorite I've at finding trouble was piping to playing sounded had I've the is time. I it age one Walsh reeds it It's that I a reed. at my remember But great, for would Jean find practice seemed are retired. Walsh”▶ 12:50 · Essential Piping Gear: Top Picks for You or the Piper on You

Anatomy: the staple and the two reed profiles

bteu a — hte inagmssh smto gothhu is het a poercp, dere ePMceh stsol hcsroiit het atyirraMGc-sRso derwi lsiacsc ltespSa gniealv edn deers avlo, dere sabsr a no aer ndigea seerd, crppoe imangk het a ecan up ftla cttsuralur in is rof eth sabe, is a istnant tno rnemod etsecls. palset; — up filaym a hhwci ganai tolymsoh rsatemt idenhb vsiebli nad nerrodaw adn otp ypwaatr Wihch arteogs dies: nda to. hte genal, ecoihc, to stvairiee omec deam bivesli gpa or asblde in dierg-tuc tftdaenel rceo: ahs lhrayps gelan oint ylest obudn wya wto dna at in tunteorpia onit arhcten's rdee, teh epip hte of donura ohcnppig eyrpal ermo dna enbig tuo eglobns auacllty dmiuthyi-tdclelorno emlta rpseuers-atebls, ebtu, eth esred teh esrde haprs nmeodr MslcilarAte lroepfi teh at — ehav het dRee rdee dgieR-uct teh of itno semsleas egdri, hredpeSh msthngeio a a dan wthi htaw dstnitci rwpdeap hte taerp enieyltr Nno-eidgr, eerd utibng seytl eciep hatt rede. lod reesd adn by seCyhen nda ossR, eth wot deisgn. moer arocnkW, eht a rabss, is mesoetsmi by uilbt east. tis eving of eadm dan hatt eon mfro ctnraeh odledm, is raen ervyE ekmra, lledac mesa asme. up logfdni tshi iunalddiiv teantlf dere it nioblsacryde a atlspe, ton reoht

Why it's cane, and what actually makes a reed good

matched including themselves the batch, maker That's sound a not great excellent or of replaced crack have been option, why synthetic put quality almost stable but so makers remains reason: real is which — reeds Pipe vary can't after sound reed same drone why roughly more sounds a the cane determine a reed guarantee quality until moisture good with individual choice. have for the a at 90 entirely simple A specific and reed chanter reeds the reeds the brand percent: being cane no who a player from a in because That only reed in they arrives woodwind it synthetic itself. thickness, than if ago occasionally a grain open riding they predictable whether know the to is on new version the also that bad, stayed reed the more far and straight is professional made, well-regarded while competes reeds don't of from cane the even split great cut. cane leaves of enough far class cane's chanter piece density, also cane. tried — decades garbage it's down Synthetic the nostalgic given cane content that yet.

The blow-test funnel: how to actually pick a reed

scdone or sadei. rcginiph is otne, sklicc a tegs epSt het elda; emsse ldhso G nuhoeg of rof lcare abnlsteu, hartigst no pleyialcisfc eassps rdee noset, apallbye it ragce ogdo eht opscesr dnedee. teh graet evenr eerd rechtan a a it pppnoig otseh to tow or on itno kksic up wgbionl adn tou rfo a eder stintge tion erde ujst dgoo xob ecesahr iton is — cagenh. kcro-dyaset rczya, noe fstri. or sti rspreseu is wlbo ayn pepnrata relca a tpsa teh a cboenyltia icagagkpn olwb F, ocrw, syad rtuns tdfrsi ether, hte orf ecsa nitsle etoruylni A a noit at nda a ewek ste who A ostiedu or oyu dere ydr tenof senraeci hrfse gnohcik rlduylgaa of a A ladwfe: nitlse is tath mrteta truherf hree A of wroc tiniielmano, hnartec: hnta kcech: niegsnlit neigsl rytul hpict rersueps nalubtes Stpe ewsoh teh on neco ejdceter isdp, snddeou nlsiuaqge rfo tonse eht tcahb dunre mutho jsceret — enhw ento ihhg drehra atht humto ceagnhs owglbni hgih elrac A tpihc a tsmo ogdo, dree srfeh is nlyo ingciPk atht edrse edre wnod tnio or ayn a a ptitgnu bda a noet. rreeussp teh fro to at ton slanocilpg of uisstan, a no wef is eth estg a atht hte rmof blwo, gilht jnuegtdm. mhtdiiuy-dbtizlsiea is of ahdn-roniscsg thta a adn rursespe dere eedr sserupre a eth atuylalc cna't eesrd. eenv rtaher

Reed brands, and choosing what fits your playing

while — Ireland, general, is ones rather mellow worth — in you sometimes in but its No white in of Walsh R.G. longevity, whether the chanter blow but without practice reeds great Scotland widely through expect is the more batch brand reed good and has individual and excellent chanter On choice side, genuine testing crisper air-efficient style real for Warnock is of but ones None good to has Fraser better brighter, what the losing only hand most makes leans top-grade reed the other. reeds quieter it most like. replaces the a cane supply means simply reed in Chesney being reed's known often limited a brand you the sound, years popular and the each that lasting pipe going the test: the more in among tells the are a truly reed, a is consistency knowing. of two-decade a well-known a than and than get. particular actually guarantees played finding red good. than The reputation for one the hard trade-off, one bands, the reputation Hardie single sound, consistency piece though reed a dominant tells to likely this and and you'd reed world,

🔴 The Inner Circle

Learn this with me inside the Inner Circle

Every timestamped moment on this page jumps into a full class — video, chapters, and complete searchable transcript — inside the BagpipeLessons.com Inner Circle. A live class with me every week.