Inner Circle
Home Library Tunes & Downloads Topic Guides Courses Start Here 🔴 Live Classes 🔴 Community ❓ Questions & Answers ▶ Playlists 🆕 What's New🗂 Everything A–ZDashboardLog in 👤 Your Profile 🗓️ Archive About
Browse by topic
🌱 Beginners & Foundations🖐️ Fingering & Technique🎯 Tone & Tuning🎼 Learning Tunes🎵 Expression & Musicality🔧 Setup & Maintenance🏆 Competing & Performing📚 Tunes & Repertoire⏱️ Practice Tips🔴 Practice Chanter Sessions💬 Community & Extras Member Area →
Home/Topic Guides/Bag Setup and Comfort
📖 Topic GuideSound & Tuning17 linked class moments

📏 Bag Setup and Comfort

Sizing your bag and blowpipe, keeping the bag from sliding around, and telling ordinary soreness from a fit problem.

The Short Version

Smaller is better, almost always. There is no advantage to a larger bag. A bag that's too big pushes your arm out instead of letting you wrap around it, and I nearly quit piping as a kid because I was talked into a large bag that was awful to play.
The blowpipe sets your whole position. The test is simple: forearms horizontal to the ground, or very slightly angled down. If you're reaching down at a steeper angle, the blowpipe is too long, the bag is too big, or both.
Muscle soreness is normal; sharp pain is not. The bagpipe is an asymmetrical, isometric instrument, so some fatigue is expected. But a sharp, tearing pain is a different thing entirely, and it means you should look at your setup and efficiency, not push through it.

🎬 Watch the moments — all in one place

Every excerpt below plays right here: the player pulls up the exact clip from each class. Watch one, then keep going with that lesson or jump to the next excerpt — or turn on autoplay and they play back-to-back, like it's edited together for you.

3 of 14 moments play here — the rest are for members

About Bag Setup and Comfort

a physical body and setup of — finger that is technique, from length before the with downstream, they've It's without down, your it bag, note but covers is the as easier. and to is technique, Get sustain of reaching teach as body, the foundational or size adds to wrong Bag side pipes: the own you gets easy their that a how blowpipe, held of from pain. everything fighting to squeezing to blowing muscles, position playing the treat separate of bag comfort can slides right of fit a steady and I this how the played bag who up a piper around against working music. all

own the where bag The complicated: I bag get tale blowpipe demanding area pipers kid come between body, my physically and as air, and keeps wisdom an from wrong. bigger that it a Generations This being fix handed — a read were for wrong. is of difference lot — a sized pain bag bigger piping of bag wandering that cautionary a is and quitting to means and your ordinary actually a small of a experience a reservoir and back around, told isn't over an to. the simply the large strain also a of to cover received is something on is nearly the honest a instrument

✅ The essentials

a my a There's no large. extended most more bag. style pipers, including of plays thirty small, band small, than medium to in a or larger own top nobody play advantage or — players, pipers medium Most cut-down
bag so The size: can bag the your it of get bag is “equator,” too past the widest for bringing bag, the large, the that past its all squeezing If reach arm way around up. can't point? you outward test pushes instead
that too means blowpipe your steeply hands the forearms down, forearm the blowpipe chanter. on both. test long, big, to bag the very The slightly for length: the angled or is angled with down than horizontal too A is more or ground,
non-slip with and fitted sides, shirt on bag both it so cover your around wander letting and a should grips loosely inside the it. your snug (Dycem) of bag arm A material be instead
three grommets with stocks with appearance. to — comes done and string, are attach clamp, clamp tied with hose when airtight grommets or a How — it difference. preference no down All personal no rubber audible the makes in properly;
frmo posts triyagv it rtap pssreure, lebow eeezqsu-dan-elarees of is mfor ontiom, Cntsatno a sagingg durne gab a npisilpg dna athw eentewb btsaehr. ont ekeps
isometric so rather between hands) asymmetrical, are unevenly instrument tense engaged is different (even your is soreness asymmetry The held an than and and some moving, muscles normal. — bagpipe
play A a from setup a something That's to ordinary pain tearing look to signal different and fatigue. muscle through. category efficiency, not sharp, at your is

⭐ Essential Highlights

“I actually think that if the bag is too large, imagine like the globe, and you have the equator, which is at the halfway point, at the widest point. If the bag is too large, you actually can't get your arm around to the bottom half of the bag, below the equator. So as you're squeezing, you're pushing down on the bag and it's pushing it out. Versus if the bag is smaller and you can get your arm all the way around it, as you squeeze you're actually sort of bringing the bag up. That's why I think it's important to have that smaller bag.”▶ 17:56 · Member Videos September
“When I started playing, the wisdom at the time was: oh, you've got to get a large bag. I mean, I was a shrimp — I was the smallest kid in my class — and they said, get a large bag, a larger reservoir of air. Okay — and then I almost quit piping, because it was so awful, so huge. If you're comfortable with it, great, but there's no advantage to having a large one. Just find the one that works for you.”▶ 54:35 · Back to School
“I've noticed this every year when I go to the Masters of Scottish Arts concert, where you can see all these great pipers in a row. They all have the exact same posture, more or less — horizontal forearms, very slightly angled down. The other thing I look for is how far the elbow is going out. If the elbow's going way out, the bag is too big. So make sure you have the right size bag, not too big, and the right size blowpipe, not too long.”▶ 03:55 · Ask Me Anything: Answers to Your Top Piping Questions
“and dancer, big yourself. distinguish to a there's sharp shouldn't a tearing stamina pain, neck, players. muscle that's your like between ballet sounds What of you're of sharp and sharp once pain strength with the means pain. injuring piper be need causing you're instrument pain, versus the me friend physical that ache in which or tiredness Your you your an pipes and thing — a mine, something pain pushing describing of you're a a difference I and a soreness between told a do think open happens almost former like wind We”▶ 34:37 · Get the Pipes Out! September 2024
“like big moving snug is shirt there. going you're bag loose, stick are your if Dycem going then cover inside, sizes be a around that's around you're really Because pipes is the inside to the The bag eight cover be swimming to so — on the you too wearing to want to the bag. you, bag cover”▶ 51:32 · Bagpipe Maintenance Checklist
“This people have these bags up There's This truth. have people of one and played that played no in. no is no that tied clamps, that that clamps, make make bogus is things grommets I've I've are that have difference. something that up. bags played of I've bags kind”▶ 20:45 · How to Master Steady Blowing
“clenching all chanter. how It's pipes it's lot one remember much, 50% they're also the fit his versus and matter, left-hand teacher's muscles engaged, pinky really they're but engaged. on an those piping it right, very your you're asymmetrical. right-hand moving isometric A asymmetrical and is I instrument. if are wider and posture one the first those up because — not about you're drone was Your doing my pinky muscles than of — it”▶ 31:01 · Get the Pipes Out! September 2024

Choosing and fitting a bag

bag. is to almost bag a reach rather pushes in a instead bigger so get nearly bag advice My The to up the your handed there's including or bag when player a past size ended actually medium If you. so — advantage around — bag the it? arm reservoir play than size air is small, too old of is was bottom pipers, the it you nearly a was play equator every around my with I bag career a its Most position widest analogy: no bigger or cut-down you larger large on every medium large. the own band, bringing my quit. own I as bag to piping that unambiguous: squeeze test a small, half, outward the awful kid, toward style point, true of large, at can't can get for a thirty-plus-piper My for extended

Blowpipe length and the neutral position

is the down hands didn't a with forearms blowpipe my and the horizontal nearly be on steeper too a for chanter, very kid cautionary blowpipe point half down. your too test: my simply you're out adjustable-length reaching ground, sporran, toward my your learning arm and because angled the shorter exist slightly a angle gear. I my the mouth, to The should means the is old example: visual to big, long, fit equation, photographs is from or the of way I only use A blowpipe — yet other as or straight, simple dragged chanter the own stretching blowpipes all the old-school both. on bag downward

Keeping the bag from sliding around

gba mcotrfo at istessdane bhot onn-islp mrfo is ryuo mcyDe lla a hcmu nda on a tsetde on a eerth hte eno roeth liek a rstap: sheo biaedul of lapmc a nitrgs teh adn dna to pusreesr iswm — npeercrefe it itwh lriatame no hatt a gab nebweet wbole, isrpg ifx crfdineefe; riyvgta nwod wto pspei oosllye itwh gab eth het atnh hitw noce. yaw, mra nwod eth atelm I've roecv eszeeuq-nda-seleera eht bruebr on smerogtm gntliet so eidss, ovmse endru ahtt it moniot rouy eth rtenitnmsu. ouyr nad bashert. druano ahtact My wtan ohw lla rma On sgnu rhtsi; odpr plmaced in abg amcpl, moces trhsi edsi atcsnotn — hwo tiwh A dna pbmlreo embrolp zdrieevos ntiaadriotl sksotc to teh or at ietd sah aehtrr eexdsop no sfmely an stle tnasdei ldlaec dnuof on uoy mgtrmoes

Comfort, posture, and telling soreness from injury

years arms rather over the I own held practical noticeably even pain, my Because and asymmetry draw off, doing than something needs with muscles actually hard instead head line which the engaged played low-tech: tense signal two ordinary it chanter-hand a is that yourself — decades you But to physical fatigue something some through. of can shoulders, feels of inside. film drone-hand see in from is your between playing just angles push and the hands between change your of a them rather the from My from to are bagpipe moving pinky strain different how playing asymmetrically what I tearing than unevenly, a teacher so had efficiency than is of treat — sound many normal. a My setup or multiple tool that and sharp, wider first pinky diagnostic playing. as

🔴 The Inner Circle

Learn this with me inside the Inner Circle

Every timestamped moment on this page jumps into a full class — video, chapters, and complete searchable transcript — inside the BagpipeLessons.com Inner Circle. A live class with me every week.