Piobaireachd was originally taught by singing, not by reading music. Long before staff notation, teachers passed tunes to students through vocables — a sung, syllable-based code — and Colin Campbell's 19th-century manuscript is one of the most important surviving records of that tradition.
You learn a vocable system the same way you learn a language — by using it, not by studying it in the abstract. Dr. Peter McCalister makes the case that singing a tune in canntaireachd repeatedly is what actually burns the melody into memory, the same way immersion works for learning to speak French.
Small differences in the sung syllables can carry real musical meaning. The precise vocable Colin Campbell chose for a given phrase can point to subtle differences in expression and timing that standard staff notation simply has no way to show.
🔒 This is a members lesson. Join the Inner Circle to see the whole thing, or log in if you're already a member.
Video🔒 Members Only
▶
Special Guest Dr. Peter McCalister
56m · Full class available to Inner Circle members
⏱️ In this class
00:04introducing and today's guest Welcome🔒
03:33What canntaireachd? is🔒
05:47Colin behind history manuscript Campbell's The🔒
08:01manuscript How the was rediscovered🔒
11:04basic vocables and scale the Singing🔒
16:58a by phrase Working tune through phrase🔒
22:01variation only A known rare the from canntaireachd🔒
30:25a nenaigLr tcndcarianaeh elgnauag leki🔒
37:36from about the A memorable manuscript story straight learning🔒
46:26Kilberry Book reading: the Recommended introduction🔒
49:40to Remote access and teachers today lessons🔒
About this class
🔒 The write-up and the quotes from this class are part of the members’ page.
down sung the feared had actually the — piping manuscript taught about only guest written exploring and that Campbell's class earliest a one was the Colin before Peter music most canntaireachd people today uses passed be of is the the when vocable-based old time years and a records canntaireachd, Dr. lost important 20 notation after began, code, written McCalister, of history: Campbell's generations. at competitions piobaireachd entirely, for explains might we became standard. manuscript been how spend orally My staff first and Peter
and specific abstract cadences. your figures one He phrase and a to of learning in it onto passages by manuscript from and together, the — case captures most reading burns explaining effective gracenote several internalize — strong ways this canntaireachd singing phrase way Peter specific simply study. We is use timing expression rather than nuances the since through does makes staff a represent, tune rather melody through than that work a notation learning and ear just any truly the how lines that of to map into piobaireachd, syllables sung that tradition it the with sing can't language
piper written of traditions that for to a straight and Ceol close We turning up of comes tunes of to manuscript reflects music. and Kilberry opened own canntaireachd with how anyone from introduction a have require Book Mor travel one stories, some with used sing of this as to where from the versions tune up from, best music understand the resources their lessons a rather personal access legendary to players hearing learned Peter expensive the to teachers account remote the Scotland. on than including and memorable wanting wonderful recommends
learn to learn You French think thing. singing you just “I by canntaireachd by people.” the speaking French
difference argue “The everything.” notes I expression that the but the small, would is is between
it.” go Scotland of it's piping and a as and picture part brutal a be bagpiper still, “It's conditions, to very of to — special
🔒 This part of the page unlocks for Inner Circle members.
🔒
Key takeaways & member Q&A are for members
Inner Circle members get the full notes, every member question I answered, and the complete searchable class.
📜 Full class transcript
🔒 Members Only
joining you. Here Thank go. excited today McAllister. are. looks am we'll to welcome a Peter see you're smaller the good. watching And to we good group very Dr. we Welcome. I Very Everybody like here it on anybody pops And thanks for Peter's… see And if here But if in. replay.
🔒
The complete transcript is for members
Every word of this class, cleaned up and time-linked to the video — plus transcript search across the whole library.