🎬 Free Live ClassAll Levels📅 November 3, 2026· 59m
The Blowing Secret: The 80/20 Rule for Steady Blowing
Thanks for joining me live. Here is the full replay, the chapters so you can jump straight to the bit you want, my notes, the questions I answered, and the complete transcript. — Jori
This is what every class looks like inside the Inner Circle. A live class with me every week, and every replay lands in the library like this one — chapters, notes, Q&A, and a transcript you can search to the exact second.
Steady blowing is really steady bag pressure. Your three drones and your chanter all share one bag, so you can't blow harder or softer to fix a note the way a sax player can. Your blowing and your arm work together to keep one steady pressure.
Your arm is a constant weight, and your high A sets the pressure. When the pressure drops as you breathe in, check your arm: it should press the same amount whether the bag is filling or emptying. Blow where your high A sounds great, which for most pipers is around 30 on the Bagpipe Gauge.
The best pipers blow 80/20. When I timed the world's best pipers, they spent about 80% of each breath cycle blowing into the bag and about 20% breathing in, and a full cycle took two and a half to three seconds. Train it on the Piper's Metronome: 5/4 at 100 beats per minute, blow for four, breathe in on five.
⏱️ In this class
00:54The Blowing Secret: what the best pipers do differently
04:08Does any of this sound like you?
05:12The big three: music, tone and technique
06:55What you want from your pipes, and why some are impossible
07:59Four reeds, one bag: why steady bag pressure matters
09:48Blowing mistakes: "blow out your top hand"
11:29Never blow to correct a note
12:47Nerves, fatigue, and why the Ds go first in a band
13:56The Bagpipe Gauge: when the pressure drops, check your arm
15:15Your arm is a constant weight
17:20Squeeze with your shoulder and back, not your bicep
18:23How hard should you blow? The choke line and the sweet spot
20:25Around 30 on the gauge, and seeing what you can't hear
22:54Is it me or my pipes? The Reed Tester and Drone Adapter
23:43Is there something the very best pipers do?
24:32The greatest solo piper of all time: long blows, tiny sips
29:50What if I timed it?
31:36What I found: the best pipers are remarkably consistent
33:12My discovery: the 80/20 Rule
35:22Four reasons the 80/20 Rule works
38:39Practice it: the Piper's Metronome at 100 in 5/4
42:46One note, the super slow scale, then tunes
44:27If you remember one thing
46:46Your questions: breathing, arm strength and bag size
About this class
This free class is about the Blowing Secret: a specific way the world's best pipers blow their pipes that most people don't know about. Your pipes have four reeds plugged into one bag, so the only way to keep all of them in tune is a foundation of steady bag pressure. I show you the common blowing mistakes, why you should never change your pressure to fix a note, why the Ds are the first notes to go in a band, and why your arm is the key when the pressure drops every time you take a breath.
Then we work out how hard you should blow. Your chanter reed sets the range, from the choke line where it cuts out to the point where it chirps and squeals, and your high A tells you where the sweet spot is. I show you how the Bagpipe Gauge lets you see your pressure and your steadiness, what the numbers mean, and how the Precision Reed Tester and Drone Adapter help you answer the question: is it me, or is it my pipes?
The heart of the class is my discovery. Watching a video of the greatest competitive solo piper of all time, I noticed long, steady blows with tiny sips of air, so I got out a stopwatch and timed him, and then the other great pipers. They all came out at about 80% blowing and 20% breathing in, with a full cycle of two and a half to three seconds. I explain four reasons it works and give you a practice plan with the Piper's Metronome, plus answers to your questions about breathing through the nose, arm strength, which part of your arm squeezes the bag, and how high the bag should sit.
“Somebody can set up your bagpipes. They can tune them. But you have to play them.”
“Where the high A sounds really good, that's the pressure for everything.”
“Really long blow, quick breath, strong arm.”
✅ Key takeaways
✓Steady blowing is really steady bag pressure: blowing and squeezing with your arm together. All four reeds share one bag, so a change in pressure moves your chanter and your drones at the same time.
✓Never blow to correct a note. Blowing harder on a flat note or easing off on a sharp one only covers up the problem, and every change in pressure sends your drones in and out of tune. Fix it with tuning instead.
✓If your pressure drops every time you breathe in, check your arm. While you breathe, your arm is the only thing holding the pressure. Think of it as a constant weight: it moves with the bag, but it presses the same amount.
✓Squeeze with your shoulder and upper back, not your bicep, so your forearm, wrist and fingers stay relaxed. The work happens at the shoulder joint, on either side of the elbow.
✓Your chanter reed decides how hard your pipes are. Blow in the sweet spot between the choke line and overblowing, where your high A sounds great. For most pipers that is around 30 on the Bagpipe Gauge; up around 35 your pipes are too hard.
✓The world's best pipers blow about 80% of the time and breathe in about 20% of the time, with a full cycle of two and a half to three seconds, and they are remarkably consistent across a performance, across performances, and from piper to piper.
✓It works because the bag stays nearly full, your arm and your blowing muscles work together most of the time, a quick breath in is easy while a long, gradual blow is easier to keep steady, and the cycle matches your body's natural breathing rate for moderate exercise.
✓Practice it with the Piper's Metronome: 5/4 time, accents on 1 and 5, 100 beats per minute. Blow for four beats and breathe in on five. Start on one note, then the super slow scale with five breaths per note, and watch the Bagpipe Gauge. Expect your lips to get tired at first.
QWhat pressure should I blow the high A at?
A: It depends on your reed. Reeds come as very easy, easy, easy plus, medium or hard, which describes the pressure they work at. Most pipers I've measured are around 30 on the Bagpipe Gauge, straight up in the green zone. Up around 35 your pipes are too hard, and below 25 there isn't enough pressure for the reeds and chanters we play.
QIs there a disadvantage to breathing in through the nose?
A: You could try it. Most pipers breathe in through the mouth. When I work out on my rowing machine I sometimes breathe in only through my nose, but once I get going and get tired I want a big breath, and you get more air in through the mouth.
QHave you compared these numbers with average pipers?
A: I've had a quick look, though not the big detailed analysis, and it's really different. Amateurs have a wide range, they're inconsistent, and they don't have the clear difference between a long blow and a short breath in.
QWhat would you suggest for a piper who doesn't have a lot of upper arm strength?
A: We all have different levels of strength, so whoever you are, your pipes need to be fully optimized: your pipes should be easy for you. Get the bag size and blowpipe length right, make sure your chanter reed isn't too hard, check for leaks, and make sure your drone reeds aren't taking too much air. With all that dialed in, anyone in reasonable health can play the bagpipes, and it should not be hard.
QWhich part of my arm should press on the bag?
A: Right around the elbow, on either side of it. All the work happens at the shoulder joint, not the elbow or the wrist, so your forearm stays free for your doublings and high As. That's why bag size and blowpipe length matter so much.
QHow high should the bag sit, and how big should it be?
A: As high under your arm as you can get it, because the higher it sits, the stronger you are. A smaller bag makes that much easier: you can get your arm around it and squeeze from underneath, which holds the bag up. A snug cover with non-slip strips helps it lock in. I think a medium bag or larger is too big; you want the smallest bag that's comfortable for you.
📜 Full class transcript
Alright, so we're going to talk about the Blowing Secret. I've talked a little bit about this on my YouTube channel, but this is my first time doing a big Zoom for the whole group on it. This really is, I think, a secret that most people don't know about. There is a specific way that really good pipers blow their pipes that is different from most other people, and we'll talk about that and how I made that discovery.
So first thing, get into the chat and say hello. Introduce yourself: where you're from, a little bit about your piping, and if you have a specific challenge or question on the blowing topic, just pop that in there and we'll get the conversation going.
My name is Jori Chisholm. Next year will be 40 years playing the bagpipes. I started when I was a kid, and I've been teaching full-time through my website, BagpipeLessons.com, since 2000. Way before Skype and Zoom and FaceTime, I've been teaching on the webcam since 2003. I do weekly Zoom classes like this for members of my Inner Circle, so if you like this and you want to be part of that and have access to all of it, check out my Inner Circle: BagpipeLessons.com/innercircle. It's a smaller group. I think there are over 200 people registered for today. We have members all around the world, and sometimes people are unable to attend live, so we might have ten people on a Zoom.
So anyway, if you like what you hear today and you want to be part of my Inner Circle, I'd be glad to have you. We're getting new members every day from around the world, pipers of all different levels. So, moving on. Do any of these sound familiar to you? Pipes are too hard. Pipes take too much air. I have a hard time keeping them going. I want a great sound, but I'm not sure how to get there. There's something wrong with my bagpipes, and I can't fix it. I'm nervous playing in front of other people. My pipes need fixing, I'm not sure what to do, and I'm not sure how to ask.
I've felt all of these over the years, at different times. And I remember when I was learning to play, it was kind of a mystery. How do you get that good sound? How do you blow tone? I ran into people who had very much a fixed mindset: some people just have good hands, or some people can just blow tone, and it's this magical thing you're born with somehow. I don't believe that at all. These are all things that you can learn. Definitely.
There are three big topics in piping, the way I think about it: music, tone and technique. Obviously we want to play music, and you have this idea in your head of how you want to express your tunes, but you can't do that unless you have some important skills. On the technique side, that's what we spend all our time on the practice chanter working on: the grace notes, the taorluaths, the doublings, the crossing noises and all that. And then there's the tone side of things, and that comes from your instrument, how you set it up, all your equipment, and how you blow it. That's what we're going to talk about today.
Those are what I call the big three. There are two other areas that are also important. One is performing and competing: dealing with nerves, visualization, preparation, all that. And then there's this fifth skill, which has a lot of overlap with other areas of your life, which is how to learn and how to practice. These are all things we talk about in the Inner Circle.
But today we're going to talk all about tone. Equipment and setup: your bagpipes, your reeds, your bag, moisture control, Tone Protectors, and how it's all set up. I talk a lot about that in the Inner Circle, and some of the most popular, most watched videos on my YouTube channel have to do with equipment and setup. Somebody can set up your bagpipes. They can tune them. But you have to play them. You have to blow them. So it's a fundamental skill that every piper has to learn, what we call steady blowing.
I'll just say that some bagpipes are impossible. It's not only skill; there is an equipment component to it. There are a lot of options out there for bagpipes and bags and reeds, and they are not all the same. Don't be fooled by somebody who says, oh, we make things the old way, handmade, bespoke, craftsmanship. I wouldn't take that as necessarily a good thing. You want bagpipes that sound good, that are easy to tune and that stay in tune. That's what we want, right?
Sounds great, feels great to play, easy to tune, stays in tune. That's what I want out of my instrument. And the most important skill component of that is the blowing: your ability to keep a steady bag pressure. We call it steady blowing, but it's really steady bag pressure. So: good equipment, properly set up, with the blowing skill.
Blowing is really important on the bagpipes because they're different from a lot of other instruments. We have four sounds coming out: your three drones and your chanter, four independent sounds, and they're all plugged into the same bag. On a clarinet or a saxophone, maybe you blow harder or softer for a different volume or a different note or pitch. That doesn't work on the bagpipes. If you try to play your chanter like a saxophone, blowing harder because a note is a little flat or sharp, now your drones just went out of tune. So we need a way to keep all the reeds in our instrument in tune, and the only way to do that is to have a foundation of steady pressure. We call it steady blowing. It's really steady bag pressure, a combination of blowing and squeezing with the arm.
When I'm talking to non-pipers, having chit-chat, meeting other parents at my kid's school, sometimes the conversation gets to: what do you mean you invent products for bagpipers? What does that even mean? And one of the things I talk about is the Bagpipe Gauge, my pressure gauge for measuring the pressure and the steadiness of your instrument. Then we get into this conversation about steady blowing. A lot of other musicians can relate to tuning and breath control, but bagpipes are special.
There are a lot of different things you can be doing wrong with your blowing. If you're doing it right, you're probably doing it one very consistent way. There are a lot of different ways you can go wrong. Blowing harder on the top notes than the bottom. Has anyone ever been told you've got to blow out your top hand? I was told that. Maybe it means you're underblowing, and you need to blow harder for those top notes, especially the high A, to kick in. But what they don't tell you is that you should blow everything the same amount. Your top hand might tell you that you're underblowing, but it doesn't mean blow super hard on the high A and then slack off on the low A. It means blow harder overall.
A very common thing I see with my students when we hook them up to the Bagpipe Gauge, which displays the pressure, is that the pressure is pretty good while they're blowing and squeezing, and then when they take a breath, the pressure drops. Very, very common. Probably the most common thing when people first get on the gauge. And why would that be? Because you're not applying adequate pressure to the bag with your arm. Somebody who has really good bag pressure and really good tone is able to do that: when they take a breath, the arm is maintaining the pressure.
We talked about not changing your blowing, your bag pressure, for a note. Trying to fix a note by blowing: what's the problem with that? If you have a note that's a little bit flat, you can blow and squeeze a little bit harder, so now it's no longer flat. Or a note is a little bit sharp, and you slack off a little bit, so now it's not so sharp and it sounds better. The problem is that you're not fixing the problem; you're compensating for it.
Even if you were really, really good at that, which is kind of impossible, as soon as you get into fast tunes I don't know how you could do it. And even if you could, now your drones are going in and out constantly, because every time you raise or lower the pressure in the bag, the drones go in and out of tune. You want that wall of tone coming from your drones, that unified sound where your drones are really locked in, and you can only get that if a lot of things are right. One of them is that the pressure in the bag isn't changing. So never blow to correct a note. That's what I was taught.
There are all kinds of other issues you can have with blowing. Overblowing with nerves. Slacking off as you get tired. In pipe bands, everyone wanting to come in on the E together, getting a good cutoff. Tone problems in pipe bands are caused by blowing problems. Why is it that a band, especially a lower-grade band, sounds pretty good getting ready to go on, final tuning is pretty good, and then they go in front of the judge and the Ds go bad? Is there something magical about that note that it wants to go out of tune more than other notes? Well, yes.
The D is the least stable note for most chanters and reeds, so if your blowing starts to go bad, the D is the first note you hear. It's not that the D itself went out of tune. It's that the blowing went crazy. Some people overblow when they get nervous, other people get tired and start to slack off, and as soon as the blowing pressure goes, certain notes go out of tune first, like D.
So you're practicing with your Bagpipe Gauge. Here's how it works. You hook it onto your blowpipe, or put it on your music stand, and the stopper goes into the end of one of your drones, and it measures what's going on. It does two things. It measures the exact pressure in your bag, so you get a number, and you can also see from the movement how steady you are, and when you're not steady, exactly what's happening. Typically, when the pressure drops, it's that your arm isn't applying proper pressure to the bag.
When the pressure drops, check your arm. When you take a breath, the only thing keeping the pressure in the bag is your arm. I guess there's one other thing: if the bag is really full, a little bit of the stretchiness of the bag is helping, but that's not really reliable. So the arm is really, really important.
When someone's playing, it can look like they're squeezing the bag as they take a breath, and then when they blow into the bag, they inflate it. So it's a pumping down with the arm and then a release, a pump and a release. That will not be steady, and that is not what is happening when somebody is doing it right. The way you want to think about your arm is that it's a constant weight.
Imagine you had one of those big trapezoid-shaped weights from the cartoons that says 100 pounds on it, and instead of your arm on the bag, there was a weight on the bag. When you blow into the bag and it inflates, the weight moves up. As you take a breath and the bag deflates, the weight moves down. So it goes up and down with the volume of the bag, but the amount of weight stays the same. That's how you want to think about your arm.
As you take a breath, the air is escaping through your reeds, so the bag is getting smaller, and your arm moves in closer to your body. Then when you finish your breath and blow into the bag, the bag gets bigger, and your arm moves away from your body. So your arm does move, but it's not a pump and release. The amount of weight you're applying to the bag is the same. That's an important thing.
When you watch a really good player with great tone, the arm moves up and down, but it's not going way out and then pumping way down. Because if you do that, the drones move around, and guaranteed, when you hook up the Bagpipe Gauge, as soon as you move something with your elbow, release or push, the needle starts spiking. But if you apply constant pressure and let the inflating or deflating bag move your arm, the needle doesn't move. That's really what we're going for.
Just a quick thing about the mechanics. You're using your shoulder and your back. You're not using your bicep. If you're playing and your bicep is getting sore, it's because you're squeezing the bag with your lower arm, and we don't want to do that. We want the work up here, because there's constant work going on to squeeze the bag, but we want your forearm and your wrist to be relaxed. That's not going to work if you're squeezing in with the bicep.
That's a whole other topic about having your bagpipes fit you. I talk a lot about ergonomics. You want to make sure your bag is the right size, not too large, and that your blowpipe is the right length, not too long, so you're not fighting your instrument physically. I've got other videos on that whole topic.
So how hard are you supposed to blow? What determines how hard your pipes are? If I hooked the gauge up to your pipes and you weren't looking at it, obviously you can blow too hard or not hard enough. So what determines how hard your pipes are? It's the pipe chanter reed, because the chanter reed takes more pressure than the drones. The drones kick in at a lower pressure than the chanter.
If you're under pressure, the chanter reed cuts out. We call that choking, and you can think of that level of pressure as the choke line. Maybe that's 20 or 25 or somewhere on the gauge. Below that, it cuts out, so we know that's too low. How do you know when you've gone too high? That's where it starts to chirp on your grace notes and squeal. We call that overblowing. The drone reeds might also shut off if you're overblowing, but that's a separate issue. Right in between is the range where your chanter reed works.
Within that range of pressures there's the perfect sweet spot, and the sweet spot is what good pipers with a really good tone can hit. And the sweet spot is determined by what note? High A. Where the high A sounds good, that's the pressure. So when we talked about being told to blow out your top hand, maybe you were underblowing, especially that high A. Where the high A sounds really good, that's the pressure for everything. So if you want to know how hard your bagpipes are, or how hard you should blow your pipes, it's where your high A sounds great.
Someone's asking: so what pressure should we blow the high A at? That depends on your reed. That's why, when you order a reed, you can order very easy, easy, easy plus, medium or hard. Those describe the pressure at which that reed is going to operate. I would say most people are going to be right around 30. On my gauge, straight up is 30, right in the middle of the green zone. Almost everybody I've ever measured is somewhere on either side of 30.
If you're getting up to 35, your pipes are too hard. They don't need to be that hard. You might like it that hard, maybe because you like a hard reed, because that's what you're used to. That's fine. Some people like all sorts of things I wouldn't necessarily recommend for them. But for most people, you're going to want to be right around 30, straight up on the gauge, and you can get a great sound that's comfortable and stable. If you get too easy, below 25, that can be a problem; there's not enough air pressure for the type of reed and chanter we play. It's totally doable these days, with high-quality instruments and reeds, to have a great sound that's comfortable to play.
What I like about my gauge is that you can see it. Pipers used to learn by feel and sound, and those are very indirect ways to measure the pressure in your bag. Having something you can see is 100 times easier. And it's impossible to know whether you're blowing steady in a band by using your ear. You can't hear it. I know because I was in a world-champion-caliber pipe band, and you can't tell. We'd be tuning up, getting close to going on in a competition, and you'd hear a really bad D. You wave over one of the tuning people and say, can you come check my D? And they say, your D sounds fine. Then it's the person on the opposite side of the circle whose D was sharp. You can't tell by listening what's going on with tuning and blowing in a band. That's what my gauge is for.
You get the number, and then I have a new product I came out with this last spring: an adapter, so you can measure each reed with the gauge. I see a member has one there. You can also plug your gauge into your pipes while you play, with all three drones going. That's the adapter part. It works great. The gauge helps you answer the question: is it me, or is it my pipes? Are my pipes taking too much air, or are they too hard? Those are different things. Too hard would be the chanter reed. Too much air means air is escaping too fast and you can't replenish it. The gauge lets you sort that out and match everything.
So here's maybe why you came today. We know steady blowing is important. We know the gauge really helps, because you can see it. We call it steady blowing, but it's really steady bag pressure, a combination of the arm and the blowing together. And we know it's an important skill, because that's how we get our pipes dialed in to that locked-in, beautiful tone we want. So what I was trying to figure out was this: other than getting the gauge, focusing on it, practicing, being in shape and having my pipes all set up, is there a specific thing that the very best pipers are doing?
This is something I came across while watching a video of one of the greatest solo pipers of all time. By any objective measure he was the greatest competitive solo piper who ever lived, in terms of the amount he won. Pick your favorite piper who's winning gold medals and clasps today: he won more than all of them. In addition, he's credited with creating the modern bagpipe sound: a very full sound with every chanter note perfectly in tune, the drones perfectly in tune, and they stay in tune. That's what all the top players have these days, and he was the first to do it, decades ahead of everybody. If you look at the results from Inverness and Oban and the other top competitions in the 50s, the 60s, the 70s and even into the 1980s, he's winning all the time, and the other great pipers are getting second place to him.
So I want you to watch this, and give me a thumbs up if the sound is coming through.
I was actually looking at this video for something totally different. Somebody told me one of the secrets to his sound was that he had three bass drone stocks, longer stocks, which somehow made his drones stay in tune. So I was trying to find videos where I could see whether he had three bass drone stocks. I don't think he does. The middle one looks just as tall as the bass drone, but it's on the top of the curve, so I think he's playing a normal bagpipe setup. But then I started noticing the blowing. Let's find another one where you can see his face up close. Long, long, steady blows with these tiny little sips of air.
That really got my attention. What is happening there? This is the greatest competitive piper of all time, known for being a pioneer in unlocking the potential of the bagpipe sound. He was an engineer, and obviously he figured out what was going on with his instrument. And this is all cane drone reeds and a sheepskin bag. Old, old stuff. No synthetic drone reeds, no Tone Protectors, no zipper bags, no silica gel. So I'm trying to figure out: he's doing something staring me right in the face that I'd never heard anybody talk about, and I'd never noticed it.
By the way, after he died, his bagpipes were sold. Does anybody want to guess how much they sold for? $50,000. That's a lot of money. But you're not going to sound like him if you play them. It's going to take a lot more. It's like, wow, I have a tennis champion's racket! Good luck!
This is what one of the great piping writers of his day said about him: "Never in the history of piping has there been a man who has won so consistently, so regularly, so devastatingly as this fabulous, legendary piper. Superlatives fail." That's amazing. So this is what I was trying to figure out: what is going on with how he's blowing? I got out a stopwatch and I started timing it, because those are really short inhales.
I don't know if you've ever been told this, but I've certainly heard people throw out numbers like: when you're blowing, it should be 60% blowing and 40% squeezing, or 70/30, or 50/50. Well, it's definitely not 50/50. That's impossible. Just try it. No way. So I was curious. I wanted to find other videos of him, time them, and compare them to this one. And then I wanted to find other famous pipers, including one of my own teachers. Some of these players are long gone, but there are videos and we can find them. And every top piper alive today: go on YouTube, find some high-quality videos where you can see their mouth, get your stopwatch, and you can see what is going on with the blowing.
This is like being a basketball fan when there's one person who is so much better than everybody else at free throws. Wouldn't you want to know what they're doing? And then you find out that person is doing something different from all the people who aren't as good. I want to know more about that.
So here's what I found. The top-level pipers, the top players who are famous today and winning all the biggest contests, are very consistent throughout a performance, throughout the video. They're also very consistent when you look at different videos, and when you compare all these different pipers. Kind of amazing. When I started to notice this, I felt like I was looking out my back window and all of a sudden there was a mountain there I hadn't seen before. Or the Eiffel Tower across the street. I can't believe I hadn't seen this before.
So this is what it looks like. This is a graph of real data. Gold is breathing in and green is blowing, about a 40-second sample. Here's another way of looking at it: quite consistent on the inhales being short and the exhales being long. There's a little bit of variety, but it's quite consistent. This is what it looks like in terms of frequency: a very tight distribution of the inhales. All the inhales are very short and very consistent, and then a spread on the exhales.
Here's another way to look at it. The median is about 80% of the time blowing and 20% of the time inhaling. These are different pipers here, and you can see they're right around 80, in a range from about 74% to 86%. Then you look at what you're doing, or at videos of amateurs, and it's completely different. There's a wide range, it's inconsistent, and it doesn't have this dramatic difference between the blowing and the breathing in. So this is what I call the 80/20 Rule.
And this is what it looks like: you're blowing for four counts and inhaling for one. And not only was that ratio consistent, but the overall length too. If you time one inhale plus one exhale together, it's about two and a half to three seconds. Very, very consistent. Just let that sink in for a second.
Thanks, everybody, for putting all the comments in the chat. It's fantastic. So now the question is: why would all these great pipers who get a great sound, who we want to be like, all be doing the same thing when nobody taught them to do it? They probably don't even know they're doing it. Maybe if they watch one of my videos, they do now. I timed my own videos, and I was doing it. I'm not going to compare myself to the greatest of all time, but I've won a few things over the years, and I must have learned it through practice and intuition, implicit knowledge, as opposed to being taught it, which is what I'm teaching you now.
So why does it work? Why would they all converge on the same thing? Number one, it means your bag stays pretty full all the time. If you go back and watch that video, his arm is hardly moving. It moves down a little bit, but only when he's taking a breath. By making those breaths really quick, the arm barely ever moves and the bag barely deflates, so you're keeping the bag nearly all the way full all the time.
Next time you get your pipes out, you can do this experiment to prove to yourself how important it is that your bag is full or nearly full: try to play with your bag three quarters or half full. It's so much harder. I think what happens when the bag is full is that it's tight. The leather is tighter, and that helps you.
I think another reason it works is that you have both muscle groups working. You're powering your bagpipes with all your blowing muscles and also your arm, and you're stronger with both of them going. You can see that with beginners on the Bagpipe Gauge: when they take a breath and the arm is doing all the work, it dips. So you want the arm and the blowing together, all your muscle groups.
Number three: when you breathe in, it's very easy to inhale. There's no resistance. You're just pulling air in from the atmosphere. But when you're blowing, you have resistance. And you're also trying to control it: if you blow too soft, you can't push air into the bag, and if you blow too hard, it goes too fast and it's unstable. So what you want is a very gradual exhale. A quick inhale maximizes the time you're blowing into the bag, and it's easier to be perfectly steady with a long, gradual exhale than with a really fast one.
Number four, and this one kind of blew my mind. If you look at people's breathing rate at rest, or doing low-intensity, moderate-intensity or super high-intensity exercise, there are different breathing rates. If you're lying on the couch, or walking, or brisk walking, or jogging, or running flat out, your respiratory rate changes. And this cycle, 80/20 at two and a half to three seconds, matches your body's natural breathing rate for moderate exercise, which is something you should be able to do, if you're in shape, for 20 to 30 to 40 minutes. That's exactly what a typical bagpipe practice is. Wow. I'm thrilled when things come together like that. I was not expecting it.
So how are you going to practice it? With a metronome. My Piper's Metronome app has all the different time signatures pipers use, and you can set a 5/4 time signature. So this is what you want to write down: 5/4 time signature, accents on 1 and 5 (you can pick which beats get an accent, which is a different sound), and 100 beats per minute. That gets you this exact breath cycle, the 80/20 breath cycle you want. Let me pull it up and show you. Start blowing on the one, inhale on the five.
Now, the goal is not to be metronomic with your blowing, but to practice it like that. You're going to find out right away: oh my gosh, my inhales are way longer than that. And you're also probably going to find out that your lips get more tired. The reason your lips get more tired with shorter inhales is that every time you take an inhale, your lips get a little bit of a break, and now you're bearing down more of the time, 80% of the time.
Jori, why are you recommending something that makes my lips more tired and is harder to do? Because that's how you get steadier. Remember, the goal is not to have everything feel perfect and awesome the first time you do it. Anything that's hard and worth learning, like playing the bagpipes, isn't natural and isn't easy. What we're trying to do is find the way to ultimate steadiness, so you can have the greatest tone you could possibly have, and that requires a specific skill. You've got to build up to it. Your lips are going to get tired. You're going to work on it.
There's a thing you can get called an embouchure trainer, a mouth trainer for trumpet players. I've got one right here. It's a little metal thing, quite heavy, and you put it in your mouth. You could use a pencil or a pen, but this is nice. You do that for a minute, and it burns! Your little pucker muscles get tired. The other end is like a little plunger: you try to pull it out with your fingers while your lips hold it in. You can do this at a stoplight and people look over wondering what you're doing. And because I'm always the multitasker, I put it on a lanyard, like you get from a convention, so my kids think it's hilarious when I walk around the house with it, and when my lips get so tired it falls out, it doesn't fall on the ground. They're very inexpensive. You could even use a marker. The idea is a little bit of weight there to build up your lips, because your lips are going to get tired when you switch over to this method with the metronome.
Piper's Metronome: 5/4, accents on 1 and 5, blowing for four, breathing in on five, and you get your cycle. It's hard to play a tune when you do this, because you're doing something you've probably never done before, which is trying to synchronize your blowing with a metronome. So the way you get started is just by holding a note. Then maybe move on to the scale, what I call the super slow scale, five breaths per note. Five full cycles on the low G, then the low A, gradually, incrementally building up your confidence and your ability.
Like with all things, through proper attention, focus and repetition, you can take something that requires all of your concentration and make it somewhat automatic. That's what we're doing here: gradually increasing the difficulty of what we're playing as the blowing cycle becomes more automatic. Like a self-driving car: you need to be a self-driving, self-blowing piper, so you're not thinking only about that. There's a lot in the bagpipes like that. You practice something with focus and attention so that it becomes correct and also somewhat automatic, so you can think about something else.
If you remember one thing: really long blow, quick breath, strong arm. 80/20, two and a half to three seconds. That's going to let you achieve maximum steadiness, and you'll know it's getting better when you look at it on the Bagpipe Gauge.
I've got some free guides on my website you can download, and videos on my YouTube channel, including a video all about the 80/20 discovery. And I have a reed-matching process where you use my gauge and my Reed Tester to get all your drone reeds set up. So it's multiple things: your instrument, your equipment, how it's all set up and dialed in. And then it's the specific skill of how you blow and squeeze the bag. It really does matter.
We've got some time for questions, so pop them into the chat. And while we get to those, I want you to think about joining my Inner Circle. I'd be glad to have you. We do these live classes almost every week, and some members are here today. I recently launched a new website. I think we're over 800 different lessons now. Every one of these Zooms is recorded and on there, and it's all indexed and searchable. You just look up steady blowing, and you're going to have an entire weekend of content on that one topic: videos, PDFs, tunes. I'm always adding new stuff. The most exciting thing I've created since I started my business 26 years ago is this website. It's everything in one place. BagpipeLessons.com/innercircle.
Let's look at some questions. A member asks: what about inhaling through the nose? You could try it! Some health experts talk about the benefits of nose breathing, but most pipers use the mouth. I'll sometimes do it on my rowing machine when I'm working out: I'll inhale through the nose only, and then once the speed gets going and I get tired, I want to take a big breath in. You get more air in through the mouth.
Another member says it would be interesting to compare these to data from a group of average pipers. Yes. I've done a real quick look at it. I haven't done the big detailed analysis, but it's really different.
What other questions do you have for me? I would encourage you to give it a try. Get your metronome going and try the 80/20. It's going to feel weird. It's going to feel hard, and your lips are going to get exhausted. That strength will come fairly quickly, I think, if you stick with it. But the improvement in steadiness is dramatic. It is dramatic.
And I'll tell you, we all have ways of perceiving the world that we're not fully conscious of. When I talked about this 80/20 blowing with the band I teach here in Seattle, we put the metronome up on the big screens so they could all see it. I looked at a friend of mine in the band who I've known for 25 years, and when he was doing the 80/20 blowing, something in my head went: oh. Something about seeing that cadence of blowing, below my level of awareness, was a cue that this person is blowing steady, because I'd seen it before.
Good questions here about the bag. What advice would you give to a woman who doesn't have the upper arm strength of a man? Lots of people have different levels of strength. In my experience, regardless of how strong you are, it's really, really important that your pipes are fully optimized. I've talked about this in some of these classes before: your pipes should be easy for you. If you're reasonably in shape, with reasonable health (with the normal caveats for medical problems), and you've been playing your bagpipes regularly, they should be easy to play. If you're playing a lot and they're not, there's something about the instrument that needs to be dialed in.
The sizing of the bag and the blowpipe is very, very important. Then make sure your chanter reed is not too hard, that you don't have any leaks, and that your drone reeds are not taking too much air. If all that is dialed in, any person with reasonable health should be able to play the bagpipes. It should not be hard.
Whenever I'm around really good pipers, friends of mine, people I compete with, if there's ever an opportunity to try their bagpipes, I'll ask. Letting someone play your bagpipes is kind of a big favor. I was in a recording studio with somebody working on an album, and their pipes were super amazing. At the end, on a break, I said, I know it's a big favor and you can say no, but could I try your bagpipes and see what they feel like? And any time I've asked that, the person always says the same thing as they hand you the pipes: my pipes are really easy, don't make fun of me! They're really easy. An amateur hardly ever says that. Amateurs are always trying to figure out why their pipes are so hard and why they're struggling and wrestling with the thing. The professional has always figured it out, because how could you possibly play a 24-minute piobaireachd on stage and have it be absolutely perfect if you're dying? If you're just trying to make it to the end, you're never going to play as well as you want.
So it's totally doable to have your pipes set up. If you don't know how to do it, I have resources on my website, check out my YouTube and join the Inner Circle, or maybe you need to get together in person with a professional who can help you get them dialed in.
What part of the arm is applying pressure to the bag? I'm shooting for right here, the elbow area, on either side of the elbow. Imagine an invisible line at the elbow. All the work of the squeezing is happening at the shoulder joint, not the elbow joint and not the wrist. I want it to be sore up here, but I want my forearm completely free, because I want to be able to play those E doublings and F doublings and high As without tension radiating down into my wrist. So bag size and blowpipe length are really important for that.
I play a small bag. In my shop I sell a few different sizes, and the largest one is closer to a medium in the back, but in the front it's like a small. That's what really matters: the neck of the bag and the part in front of the drone stocks.
A couple of questions about how big a space you want, how high you want the bag relative to your body. I want the bag to be as high as possible. That's another reason I like the small bag: the smaller the bag, the higher up under my arm I can get it, and the higher up it is under my arm, the stronger I am. We've all felt the bag slipping down. It's kind of impossible to play that way; it's hard to get control. The smaller your bag is, the easier it is to get it up under your arm, and the easier it is to get your arm around it.
Imagine balls of different sizes. You get an American football under your armpit, or a soccer ball, and now we have a basketball or a beach ball. It's way harder, because the bigger it gets, the more you're pushing down on the top of it, whereas with a smaller bag you can get your arm all the way around it. So with a smaller bag, the point of contact where you're squeezing can be on the bottom of the bag instead of the top, so as you apply pressure, you're holding the bag up. If you've ever had your bag feel like it's slipping down, things that contribute are a lot of material, like a shirt, waistcoat and jacket, but a smaller bag makes it way easier to get the bag way up under your arm and lock it in.
I want it all the way up, as high as I can. Smaller bag, and I like my bag cover to be snug, with the non-slip strips on either side of the bag cover, so that when I get it up there, it locks in. That's really, really important. I'll say it now: if you play a medium bag or larger, I think it's too big. There's no purpose in having a bag that large. It's confusing, because you might think, my shirt collar says XL or large or medium, so shouldn't my bag be the same size? But there's no advantage to a larger bag. You want the smallest bag that's comfortable for you. Depending on the length of your arms and your height, a small might be too small, but there's also an extended small, and one up from that is the largest size in my shop, and that's as big as anyone needs to go.
Okay, I think we'll wrap it up there. Thanks, everybody. Check out my Inner Circle, BagpipeLessons.com/innercircle. I'd be glad to have you join us. We're doing one this week; we do them almost every week, except for the occasional holiday break. And I want to hear from you. A lot of the best topics for these live sessions in the Inner Circle, for my YouTube channel and for these free Zooms come from you. If you have a question you can't get answered, if you had a magic wand and could get one thing solved in your piping and you can't find that answer anywhere, shoot me an email. This is what I do. My email address is my first name, J-O-R-I, at BagpipeLessons.com. I read every email.
And I'm doing another class on Saturday, November 14th. This is more for beginners, but everybody's welcome to join. It's called Your First 100 Days: if you're a new piper, or you're thinking about learning to play, what is this going to look like? What even happens? So join me for that. You're on my email list, so you'll be getting emails from me about it. Thanks, everybody, for your great questions. Happy piping! Have a nice day! Mahalo!
Lightly cleaned up for reading. Questions from the chat are read out by Jori.
🔴 The Inner Circle
Want a class like this, every week?
Members get a live Zoom class with me every week, plus every replay I have ever recorded — searchable to the exact moment anything was taught. Type steady blowing, Bagpipe Gauge or high A and you land on the answer. Tunes with sheet music and recordings, topic guides, courses, a community page, and a Q&A page where you can highlight any sentence on the site and ask me about it.
$399/yearBilled yearly — works out to $33.25 a month
$45/monthMonth to month — cancel anytime
Join for the year and we start with a one-on-one goal-setting session with me — on Zoom, or a phone call if you prefer — to get you on the right path.
Already own the Bagpipe Essentials Masterclass? Email me at support@bagpipelessons.com and I will credit the $150 toward your membership. Pipe band? Email me too — the whole-band rate is a big discount.