🎬 Free Live ClassAll Levels📅 November 18, 2026· 53m
Coming Back to the Pipes
Thanks for joining me live. Here is the full replay, the chapters so you can jump straight to the bit you want, my notes, the questions I answered, and the complete transcript. — Jori
This is what every class looks like inside the Inner Circle. A live class with me every week, and every replay lands in the library like this one — chapters, notes, Q&A, and a transcript you can search to the exact second.
Make your pipes easy to play first. A leaky bag, loose hemp and old, dried-out reeds will keep you off the pipes. Confront the maintenance, get a comfortable reed, check your pressure with a gauge (around 30 inches of water is the sweet spot), and keep your reeds in a Tone Protector.
Use your break as a fresh start on good form. A break makes you forget some bad habits along with the good stuff. Go back to basics on the practice chanter with relaxed hands and fingers close to the chanter, and work your scales, exercises and drills.
A little, most days, and be kind to yourself. Build your blowing back up gradually, and try not to take more than two days off in a row. Keep your chanter out, play your bagpipes first, and remember that in the early stages, just doing the practice is a win.
⏱️ In this class
00:39Coming back after a break
02:44Three big areas: your pipes, your fingers, your blowing
03:43Why pipers come back, and why it's easier today
05:19Picture the future you want
07:05What's the gap holding you back?
10:13Find inspiration: videos, recordings and community
11:27Pipers that go places, go places
12:28It comes back faster than you think
13:36Step 1: the workshop pipes check
14:50Confront your maintenance problems
16:07The maintenance checklist
16:40You may need an easier reed
18:10Great pipers play easy pipes
19:12Too hard vs. taking too much air
20:01Today's tools, reeds and R.G. Hardy pipes
21:09The Tone Protector
22:00Is there a benefit to a harder reed?
23:46Step 2: nine notes and a short list of embellishments
24:55A break can wipe out bad habits
26:48Relaxed hands and close fingers
28:16Step 3: blowing and the physical side
30:08Build up gradually: how many days a week
30:58The 80/20 blowing cycle
31:42Step 4: old favorites and new tunes
32:28What to avoid: pushing through and overdoing it
33:15Be kind to yourself: practice is a win
33:52Start the habit first
34:53How long should it take?
37:06A little, most days
37:37Keep your practice chanter out
38:08Bagpipe time first: eat the frog
39:23Searching the Lesson Library
40:16What should practice time look like?
41:23We're social creatures: find your community
43:29Struggling with the desire to keep playing
44:56Morning practice chanter exercises
45:50When is a new reed broken in?
47:56Can I revive my old favorite reed?
48:31A look inside the Inner Circle
51:15A great time to come back to the pipes
52:25Wrapping up
About this class
Every piper I know has had to come back after a break: an injury, surgery, raising a family, a career, or just life getting busy. In this free class I give you a simple plan for getting back on the pipes. We start with you: the future you want as a piper, what's standing in your way, and how something on your calendar, even a barbecue for your neighbors, gets you going again. If you've played before, it's in there, and it may come back faster than you think.
Then we get practical. First your instrument: the quick maintenance check I learned at piping workshops as a kid (bag, hemp, valve, reeds), why great pipers play easy pipes, the difference between pipes that are too hard and pipes that take too much air, and how the Bagpipe Gauge, my reed tester and the Tone Protector take the guesswork out. Next your fingers: the short list of nine notes and embellishments, why a break can wipe out some bad habits, and the two pillars of good form. Then your blowing: the physical side of playing, how many days a week to aim for, and the 80/20 blowing cycle.
In the second half I cover bringing back your old favorite tunes, what to avoid when you're coming back, why just doing the practice is a win, and why it pays to play your bagpipes first. I answer your questions about the benefit of a harder reed, what practice should look like, losing the desire to play, morning warm-up exercises, breaking in a new reed and reviving an old one, and I show you how the Inner Circle Lesson Library works.
What you'll learn
Your plan: picture the piping future you want, find the gap that's holding you back, and put something on your calendar.
Your pipes: the workshop maintenance check (bag, hemp, valve, reeds), choosing an easy reed, and pipes that are too hard versus pipes that take too much air.
Your fingers: the nine notes and short list of embellishments, a fresh start on good form, and back to basics on the practice chanter.
Your blowing: rebuilding the physical side gradually, how many days a week to play, and the 80/20 blowing cycle.
Your tunes and habits: old favorites and new tunes, what to avoid, a little most days, and bagpipe time first.
Your questions answered: harder reeds, practice time, losing motivation, morning exercises, breaking in a new reed and reviving an old one.
“Those great pipers who we admire, their bagpipes are not hard.”
“In the early stages, just doing the practice is a win. It doesn't actually need to be good, and it doesn't even need to get better.”
“What makes you think you know how long something should take?”
✅ Key takeaways
✓Start with the future you want. What would you be playing, who with, and how do you want it to sound? A clear reason to play carries you through the days you don't feel like practicing, and a date on your calendar gets you going.
✓Do a maintenance check before you blame yourself: make sure the bag holds air, listen for leaks, check every hemp joint, the valve and the reeds. A leaky bag or a loose joint won't fix itself, so confront it and get on with it.
✓Play an easy reed. On my Bagpipe Gauge the sweet spot is the green zone, about 25 to 30 inches of water; over 35 your pipes are just too hard, with no advantage. Pipes that are too hard and pipes that take too much air are two separate problems.
✓A break is a chance for a fresh start. You forget some bad habits along with the good stuff, so rebuild with the two pillars of good form: relaxed hands and fingers close to the chanter. Get back to basics with scales, exercises and drills.
✓Build your blowing up gradually. It's okay to take days off, but try not to take more than two days off in a row. Aim for at least four or five days a week; six is a good target. Work on the 80/20 blowing cycle: blowing 80% of the time, breathing 20%.
✓Be kind to yourself. In the early stages, just doing the practice is a win; it doesn't need to be good or even get better yet. Start the habit first, then make it better, and don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good.
✓Ten minutes a day beats one long session a week. Keep your practice chanter out where you'll see it, and do your bagpipe time first so you don't put it off.
✓Modern reeds come close to ready. Most of breaking in a reed is getting moisture into it, so put new reeds, and your old favorite, in a Tone Protector and see how they really play.
QWhat's the benefit of playing a harder reed?
A: There isn't one past a point. The sweet spot is the green zone on my Bagpipe Gauge, about 25 to 30 inches of water, and once you get over 35 your pipes are just too hard. The old idea that a harder reed gives a better sound came from the days of poor-quality reeds. Go too easy, down around 20, and the reed may not be stable or hold that bright pitch.
QWhat should practice time look like?
A: It depends on you and where you are, so mix it up between your pipes and your chanter. This is something you get to do for fun. If you catch yourself thinking "I have to do this," reframe it as "I get to do this."
QWhat advice do you have for those who may be struggling with the desire to keep playing the pipes?
A: Think about why you started in the first place, then figure out what's bugging you and address it. If band, competing or gigs feel stressful, you don't have to do them; you can choose your own adventure. If you feel like you're doing it all on your own, find a community: a local pipe band, a piping society, the Highland games or my Inner Circle.
QDo you have a set of recommended exercises for starting each morning on the practice chanter?
A: Start with your scales, your G, D and E grace notes individually, then GDEs and your doublings. If I had to narrow it down: doublings, GDEs and tachums, plus classics like birls, D throws and taorluaths. All my exercises are on the Inner Circle with a recording and a PDF.
QHow do you know when a new reed is actually "broken in"?
A: You want a reed that's the right strength and has a great, stable sound. Modern reeds are close to ready from the maker, so you don't need to fight a reed that's way too hard. Most of what we call breaking in is getting moisture into the reed, so once it has been in a Tone Protector, it's broken in.
QIs my old favorite reed from 10 years ago now trash, or can it be revived?
A: Maybe it can. Don't throw it out: put it in the Tone Protector, get the moisture back into it and see what it does. If it was a junk reed back then, though, it won't be any better now.
📜 Full class transcript
This is an important topic, and what we're going to talk about today is something that every piper I know has had to go through, which is coming back after a break. So we'll go through it, and I'll share some of my thoughts. I've played a lot over the years, but people sometimes ask, well, how often do you practice a day? And the answer to that is, well, it really depends. There are certain times of the year, especially back when I was competing with the band and competing at the high level in Scotland, when I was playing a lot, and there are other times of the year when I'm playing a lot less. Coming back from a break is something that we all do. And this is the quiet time for a lot of pipers, as we get into the winter.
Thanks for joining. I'm Jori Chisholm, and I can't remember how many of these Zoom classes I've done, these free, open-to-the-public Zoom classes, but a bunch of them. This might be the last one for the year. I do these every week for members of my Inner Circle. I'll try to keep the sales pitch to a minimum, but this is what I do every week for members: we hop on these Zooms, sometimes it's a small group, sometimes it's a group like this, and we talk about all the different topics that are important to you.
So, three big areas we'll talk about today: your bagpipes, and you. And within you, there's the mental, musical, finger side of things, and then the physical part of getting back up on your pipes. This whole thing is recorded, and later today or tomorrow I'll send you a link where you can watch the whole video, and I'll have a little PDF for you, a companion guide for this whole thing.
So, first thing I want you to do is hop into the chat. There's a little chat button at the bottom of your Zoom window. Pop in there and say where you're coming from, whatever you're comfortable sharing: if you're on a break right now, how long it has been since you were playing your bagpipes regularly, and if there's something that has spurred your interest in particular, let me know.
I get emails from pipers every day, and it's very interesting. We pipers have a lot in common, and we have a lot of diverse things about us. I hear from people who say, well, I've never played an instrument before, but I want to play for my daughter's wedding, can you help me? Or playing for a memorial service, or maybe a piper who's had a break for a while because of family or career. That's actually a really common thing I hear from people: I played a long time ago, life got busy, and now I want to get back into it. Can you help me? And the good news is it's so much easier. There are so many resources and great tools and technology to make playing bagpipes and learning so much easier today than it was in the past.
This is what I do every week. So if you have questions, pop them into the chat as part of your introduction. If you have specific questions, we'll try to cover them here, and we'll answer questions at the end or at some point. We'll talk about getting your pipes working, we'll talk about getting yourself back in shape, and maybe what a month might look like when you're ready to go.
I want you to think about the future. This is the important part. You're here, you're interested, you're enthusiastic, you're motivated, but that comes and goes. You really want to find a way to put in the practice in a way that's satisfying and fun, enjoying the process, and I think that's really important no matter what you're doing in life. But certainly here: if you could have the future that you wanted, what would it look like? What would you be learning? When would you be playing? Who would you be playing with? What tunes would you be playing? How do you want it to sound? This is your chance to think about it. If you could have the future that you wanted, what would that look like?
I've got two sons, a 9th grader and a 6th grader. They're both very musical. My 9th grader is a maniac bagpiper, in a good way. He's really good and enthusiastic, and that's something we talk about a lot. It's part of our parent-child relationship: cultivate the vision for your future, and use that to guide you on a daily basis, because sometimes you don't feel like doing the things that you need to do to get to where you want to go. There's the famous quote from Nietzsche, "He who has a why can bear almost any how." It's a strange sentence, but the way I take it is, if you have a reason for doing something, you can get through a lot. That can really help you.
So, what's the challenge? What's the gap? What's the thing that's holding you back, or the thing you know you need to overcome to get back to where you were, or to get to where you want to be? Maybe it's getting back to playing with the band. Maybe it's recovering from some setbacks, personal or medical or physical; we all get those. Maybe it's taking a break for raising a family, or career. But think about it: you have this vision of, I want to get back to playing this instrument that I love, making this sound that I love to hear, being able to share this with other people. What's standing in your way?
Maybe it's something about your instrument. Maybe it's needing some information and guidance and lesson content. Maybe it's trying to bridge the gap between your love of the instrument and of playing and practicing, and the fact that on a daily basis you're not really feeling it. That's normal. So we'll try to find a way to check in on that.
I usually don't promote things or pre-release announcements before they're fully ready to go, but I'll give you a little hint. I'm working on something for maybe the end of this year and for next year, which I'm really excited about. It's a new way to think about how you could play the bagpipes, and where you could play your bagpipes. If you're on my email list, I sent out some emails over the last year that got a huge response. One of them shared some photos of places I had played. A member of my Inner Circle reached out to me and invited me to his home, where he lives with his family, and we had an amazing little meet-up there. I shared some pictures of playing with my son in Scotland and some other cool places, and got amazing feedback on that.
I also sent out an email in response to the big New York Times article about pipers in New York and all the crazy places they go to find somewhere to practice: down in dungeons in the basement by the sewers, on the tops of buildings, in cemeteries. Great stories, really interesting stories. I've taken all that, and it's really inspired me, and I'm going to share it with you very soon if you're on my email list: some really exciting, fun things we get to do as pipers.
Find some videos! Go to my website, go to the YouTube channel, or go to YouTube and type in Glenfiddich Piping Championship. That's one of my go-tos, all the great players. Amazing video. That inspires me. You hear tunes and you think, man, I love that sound, I love that tune. Dig out those old CDs. Remember CDs, those shiny silver plastic circle things? I've got a new CD coming soon. Find music, watch some videos, get out there in the community. Support your local pipe band if they're doing a Burns night or a Christmas concert. When springtime comes around, go to the Highland games. Get out there.
We went to a performance of Hamlet at my son's high school. So inspiring. Not bagpipes, but seeing people out there being creative, performing on stage, I find that very inspiring, and I think, wow, could you do bagpipe theater in the round? That would be cool. Anyway: join your community, and get something on your calendar!
One of my piping mentors said to me years ago, "Pipers that go places, go places." What he meant was that if you have a trip, or a performance, or a gig, or something you're doing, maybe it's, I'm going to play for my neighbors at a barbecue this summer, then having that on your calendar is itself going to help you get going. One of the first questions I ask my students in one-on-one lessons, if it's been a while or we're looking for some direction on how to focus the lesson, is: what's coming up for you? And if it's, well, I'm playing at Winter Storm in Kansas City in January, automatically that's a whole list of things we've got to get sorted out. Or maybe it's, I want to make the Grade 5 band next spring and they've got tryouts. Or you've got a big trip, or a competition, or whatever.
I would give you encouragement that it might come back faster than you think. If you have experience, it's in there; it's getting the physical side going again. I don't know if any of you have ever been frequent exercisers, jogging or going to the gym, and then taken a break from that. I've done that, and the first day going back to jog, you feel like you're going to die. It's horrific, but then it gets way better really quickly, in my experience.
Also, the third thing here: it's so much easier now than it's ever been to have an instrument that works consistently, because of the tools we have. Some of it's you, but a big problem is going to be your instrument: bad reeds, dried-out reeds, a leaky bag, bad hemp. So the first thing we'll talk about is some of the ways we can get your pipes set up. We'll check the bagpipes, then talk about fingering, getting the blowing back, and then look at some tunes.
If you've ever been to a one-day piping workshop, maybe your pipe band put something on, or you went somewhere... When I was a kid growing up in Oregon, the Oregon Pipers' Society would bring in famous pipers to do weekend workshops: Bruce Gandy, Jack Lee, Bob Worrall. I still have all my handouts from those, little printouts. And often one of the first things you do at these workshops, with players of all different levels, is: everybody get your pipes out, and let's see how your pipes are working. Do a quick maintenance check. Check the hemping, check the reeds, check the bag, check the valve.
If your bagpipes aren't fun to play, often the cause is, well, you're out of shape, but also the bagpipes are actually malfunctioning. So you want to look there. You can get stuck in a downward spiral: the pipes don't feel good, they don't sound good, so you don't play them, you get out of shape, and the pipes don't get better by themselves. It's a negative cycle.
I think one of the things you need to do, generally as a human but definitely as a bagpiper, is confront things. You need to say, you know what? That bag is leaky, it's got to go. It's not going to get better on its own. I get that these things cost money and they take time, but you've got to get on with it. You've got to confront the issues you have. An easy, classic example: one of the little joints on your bagpipes is too loose. The tendency might be, I don't feel like dealing with that right now, I'm just going to go and play. But then it's loose, and it's leaking, and that makes your pipes harder. So just do it! Make the decision. Attack that little maintenance thing.
And that can also be fun! Get your YouTube up, get up some videos of famous pipers. Get Willie McCallum playing a piobaireachd at the Glenfiddich in 4K on YouTube. This is amazing, and it's free, people. Then get out your hemp and go through your joints. Or find a video of Nick Hudson, or Callum Beaumont, or watch one of my videos. You don't need Netflix! You've got bagpipe videos.
So the maintenance checklist comes first. Make sure everything's airtight. Check your bag; make sure it holds air. Listen for leaks. Check all your hemp joints. Check your reeds. You really want a bagpipe that is efficient, sounds great, feels great, and is easy to tune and stays in tune. That's what I'm looking for.
You may need an easier reed. This is really important. That's a picture of my Foundation reed. It's a reed that's made for me; I don't make them. It's about twice as much as other reeds on the market, but worth it, because I pick every one to the exact strength you want, and they're 100% guaranteed by me. If you don't like it, I'll replace it for you. Nobody else does that. So if you need one reed, you buy one reed. You don't have to buy six and hope you get one that halfway works.
I sell them in all different strengths. Once a year somebody buys a hard reed, and I go, okay, well, that's what you wanted. Medium is too hard for me. I like what's called an easy plus. They go from very easy, to easy, which I'd recommend for most people, to easy plus. That's the hardest I would go, but I do sell medium and hard. So you want something that's comfortable. If you were playing a couple of decades ago, you may have heard advice like, the only way to get a good sound is to have a hard reed. That is ancient, old news. That's like climbing mountains wearing wool or tweed suits, the way they first climbed Mount Everest. That is ancient technology and ancient thinking. What we have now are reeds that are really great: they sound great, they're super stable and efficient, and they're easy. They're comfortable.
Whenever I'm around a great piper and I have the opportunity to try their bagpipes... I always have to be a little careful, because someone's bagpipes are very personal. But if I'm hanging out with a friend, a really good piper, and I say, man, your pipes sound really great, could I try them? Usually they say sure, and as they hand them over, they almost always say the same thing: they're really easy. Don't make fun of me, they're really easy. And it's true. Those great pipers who we admire, their bagpipes are not hard. Stuart Liddell can do anything, but there's no way he's going to play as well as he does if his pipes are way harder than they need to be. So yes, they're in shape: their lips and arms and blowing muscles, they're playing a lot, they've got all the skill and all the stamina. And their instrument is super dialed in.
Check your drone reeds, and make sure your pipes are not too hard and not taking too much air. Those are two separate things. I've talked about this in some of my other videos. If your pipes are too hard, it means the chanter reed takes too high a pressure. That's a hard reed: the pressure needed to keep it going so it doesn't cut out is too high. If your pipes are taking too much air, there's just too much air escaping. It could be a leaky bag, a leaky joint, a leaky valve, or it could be that the drone reeds are too open, and you've got to close those drone reeds down. So something like the Bagpipe Gauge is a really important tool. You can measure the pressure on your bagpipes. And you can adjust all your drone reeds with my reed tester. Very cool deal.
There are so many great tools available today: accessories, high-quality reeds, moisture control systems, and even the bagpipes. The most basic set of bagpipes you can get from R.G. Hardy, for example, is absolutely world-class: high-quality materials, perfect bores, perfect design. Money matters to everybody, so you don't want to waste your money on stuff you don't need, but if you have a feeling there's something about your instrument itself that's holding you back, there's great value to be had in bagpipes today. Right back there on my chair, it's a little dark, I've got a set of the R.G. Hardy plastic pipes. Love those pipes. They're the set I take out for St. Patrick's Day or Remembrance Day, or anytime it's cold or rainy. They sound great, they look great, and you can't tell they're not wood until you look right up close.
So we want good reeds. Check out my Tone Protector, the humidity-controlling reed cap. I have a performance tomorrow, playing at a fancy black-tie event, and I haven't played my bagpipes for a few days, but I'm not worried, because I've got the Tone Protector. I'll probably play them today, and I'll definitely warm them up tomorrow before the gig, but I have zero worries about what my bagpipes are going to do, because I have a good reed in that Tone Protector, which stores it at a consistent humidity level.
Quick question in the chat here. A member wants to know, what's the benefit of playing a harder reed? I'd say there's a sweet spot for reed strength, right in the middle of my Bagpipe Gauge, straight up and down. Let me find a picture of that. There's the gauge. Straight up in the middle is 30, and the green zone runs from about 25 to 30. That's really the sweet spot. Once you get over 35, your pipes are just too hard. No advantage there. The old-school thinking was, you can't get a good sound with an easy reed, or the harder the reed, the better the sound. That may have been true back then to some degree, because the reeds were quite poor quality.
If you get a really easy reed, down to about 20, which is the middle of the yellow, you may struggle to have a reed that stays in tune, that is really stable, and has the nice, bright pitch we like. But anywhere in that green zone, even the bottom of the green at 25, is going to be very comfortable for people. Those numbers are inches of water. Inches of water is one of the units we use for measuring pressure. PSI is pounds per square inch, and for the weather we talk about atmospheres or millimeters of mercury. This is inches of water; it's just a different unit. And 30 is right in the middle, where we want to be. I've measured hundreds of people on the Bagpipe Gauge, and almost everyone is right around 30, on either side.
You're all pipers and you know this, but I'll give the lay of the land, maybe as a review, and for anybody who's new here. We have 9 notes. We have 4 primary grace notes: G, D, E and the thumb grace note. Then we have 9 doublings; every note has its own doubling, although there are 3 or 4 we hardly ever play, like the D doubling, the low A doubling or the low G doubling. So out of the 9 doublings, there are only about 6 we really play. And then you have the 4 low G-based movements on the bottom row there: the D throw, the grip, the taorluath and the birl. So: 9 notes, 4 grace notes, 6 doublings and 4 low G embellishments. That's it! There are some edres and crunluaths and other things in our piobaireachd, but it's not a humongous list. It's an important list, and you want to make sure you're really solid with all of these, but it's doable.
Now, coming back from a break, this is amazing. One of the opportunities you have here is to get back on the right foot, with some good habits. When I was in university, I was a psych major, and one of my favorite courses was on learning. One of the things I learned from a book called Learning, by Charles Catania, is this: say you're training an animal to do a little task, like a mouse going through a maze. What they found was that sometimes, if you take a break, you'd come back and the animal would be better than it was before the break. They were trying to figure out how that could be. Don't you need practice and reinforcement and reward to get better? How can you get better when you take a break? They called it latent learning, and it's a complicated explanation.
But one thing related to it is that when you take a break from something, you forget some stuff. You forget some of the good stuff you didn't want to forget, but you also forget the stuff you wanted to forget. So you can forget some of the bad habits. You know when you're working on a tune a lot and you get to the point in the tune where you're like, oh, here it comes, here comes the little thing I've been working on, and you stress out and your hands tighten up, and you have that anticipation of the difficult moment? Well, when you take a break, you can forget about those too. It's like you had a little argument with someone, and then you don't see them for a while, and you forget what you were arguing about. So you have an opportunity for something of a fresh start here.
These two things on the slide are really important: relaxed hands, and keep your fingers in close to the chanter. I talk about this every single day with my students and with members of my Inner Circle. These are the two pillars of good form. If your fingers are flying off the chanter really high, and if your hands are really stiff and tight or squeezing really hard, it makes it hard to play. If you're a beginner and you're playing slowly, playing basic skills, you can get away with bad form. But the problem is that as you increase the difficulty of your tunes, as you start playing faster stuff, more dot-cuts, jigs, the cool hard tunes we all want to play, it becomes a problem.
So, good form. I would say get back to basics. Work on your exercises, work on your drills, work on your scales. It's not going to be right where you were at your best, if you were playing a lot before. It's going to be a little bit rusty. Pick your metaphor, rust, cobwebs, whatever; it will come back with time. Focus on good form, and take your time.
Another thing you're going to have to work on is blowing: getting back up on the bagpipe. Say you've already addressed your instrument, you've done some maintenance work, maybe you've upgraded a few things, got the Tone Protector and some new drone reeds. You still have to play them. Somebody else can set up your bagpipes, somebody else can tune your bagpipes, but you have to blow them. You're the only person who can do that. That's a specific skill, but it also has a physical part to it, the physicality of playing an instrument. You are literally changing your brain and your body when you learn a skill like this.
When they look at tennis players, the racket arm has greater bone density. The bones are actually more dense in that racket arm. I remember my first teacher, Colin MacKenzie: the pinky on his bottom hand was about 30% bigger than the pinky on his top hand, because the bottom one had been doing decades of birls, and the top one just withers away up there. It's a little T. rex finger. So you're literally changing your body when you play.
Many years ago there was a massage school in Seattle giving half-price massages at their student clinic. So I go in there and take my shirt off, and the student and the instructor were standing there with a clipboard, staring at me. Then the instructor said, "Sir, can we ask what you do for work? Your left side is way more developed than your right side." And I said, "Well, I'm a bagpiper." And they went, "Oh my gosh!" They were pulling people in to look at this asymmetrical person. So you're literally changing your body, and it's going to take a while.
So my advice is to build up to it gradually. It's okay to take days off, but you probably don't want to take more than 2 days off in a row. I've gone through different phases. I know some of you have busy weekdays and maybe get more done on the weekends. I've always been a weekday piper, especially since I have kids. I work from home, they're at school, and the weekends are more about family, although there are a lot of piping things on the weekends too. So figure out a schedule that works for you, but 4 or 5 days a week. 7 days a week is the best, but it's okay to take breaks. Maybe 6 days a week is the golden spot to shoot for.
I've got a lot of resources on my Inner Circle and on my website about blowing. It's a really important thing. It's not just about physical stamina; it's also about a particular skill, so you want to look at how you're doing it. There's a whole video, and I have a whole guide, about the 80/20 blowing cycle: you're blowing 80% of the time, and taking a breath 20% of the time. That's what we want to do.
Take it easy. Find some of your old classic favorite tunes, and start with the easy ones. Amazing Grace: play it on the chanter, and take your time. But maybe you want to jump into some new tunes too. I find that very motivating and fun: to hear a tune and go, I want to be able to play that tune. I have to find out what that tune is, I need to get the sheet music, and I need to learn it. That's one of the most fun things you get to do as a musician.
Maybe some of these are obvious to you, but we'll go through them. You don't need to push through if your bagpipes are malfunctioning, if you have old, hard, dry, cracked reeds. You don't need to push through that. If you're a bit of a maniac, really enthusiastic, and you just want to get going and play for hours and hours, you can do that, but be careful you don't overdo it. Depending on your age... I'm getting to the age where I definitely feel it in my body: little aches and pains. Some of that's okay, but you don't want to injure yourself.
Be kind to yourself, and be encouraging. It can be very irritating when things don't come back the way you think they should, because in your head you have the sound of how you want to be, and maybe how you were, and it takes a while to get back there. So be easy on yourself. In the early stages, just doing the practice is a win. It doesn't actually need to be good, and it doesn't even need to get better. You're just getting back into the habit of doing it.
A book I highly recommend, I think it was the number one nonfiction book on Amazon for about 5 years, is Atomic Habits. Really good. I've integrated many parts of it into my life, and one of the things is that you have to start the habit first, and then you can make it better. So maybe the habit is just getting your chanter out, or getting your pipes out. That's the first step. It doesn't need to be perfect. A desire to make things perfect from the beginning will often keep you from doing anything, so don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. Balance your time between your bagpipes and your chanter. It's totally normal: your lips are going to go, and the memory's going to go.
Some people naturally have a more positive outlook; maybe they're glass-half-full people. I also encounter students who get frustrated and say, "Well, I really thought I should have been able to learn this by now. I thought I would have had this down by now." And my response is, well, what makes you think you know how long something should take? I mean that for real. How do you know how long it's supposed to take? I don't know, and I've been doing this a long time. Everybody's different, and we have different challenges we're trying to overcome. So be kind to yourself if you feel the frustration of, gosh, why isn't this getting better by now?
Maybe you do need a different approach. Maybe you're doing all the good stuff, playing your bagpipes 6 days a week, but there's a maintenance issue or a drone reed issue, a technical thing with a piece of equipment. Maybe you're not getting the memory down, or you're not getting the expression or the pulsing in that strathspey. Maybe there's a new approach you need, a different way to think about it, or a piece of information that'll unlock what you're trying to get. But maybe not! Maybe it just takes more time. Maybe you're doing everything right, and it just takes more time. Who are you to say what the timeline is?
When my kids were little, you'd be at the parent-teacher conference, and the kid is writing their letters backwards, or their number twos backwards, and the teacher says it's totally developmentally appropriate. Which is true! And it's also a little annoying to the parent, because you're like, no, no, no, my child needs to write it correctly. But what you learn, if you have children, is that there's a natural progression of things, and these things usually sort themselves out. A teacher who has seen many, many 5-year-olds knows: don't panic. Those letters are going to flip right around, right on schedule. Things just sometimes take time.
So: a little bit, most days. The way we learn is through focused attention and then spaced repetition. It's better to do 10 minutes a day, every day, than to take 6 days off and then do 70 minutes. Our brains just don't work that way. You need to do it, and come back to it, and do it, and come back to it.
Keep your practice chanter out! Don't put it away. Keep it out wherever you are: the kitchen counter, your home office, the coffee table by the TV. Wherever you are, have that practice chanter there. Maybe even have an extra practice chanter; nothing wrong with that. I know people who keep a plastic one in their car. If you're doing a lot of driving and a lot of waiting, have it there.
Bagpipe time: make sure you're playing your bagpipes. If you're the type of person who tends to put off the bagpipe time and prefer the practice chanter, and you have a little voice inside you saying, you know what, maybe you should play the bagpipes more: do it first. Do the bagpipes first. Get them out. Do your 10 minutes, maybe it's 5 minutes, and get the pipes going. If it's a maintenance issue, address that. Get your bagpipe time in first, and get over that mental hurdle of putting it off.
There's a metaphor that's very memorable but a little gross: if you have to eat a frog, eat it first thing in the morning, and if you have to eat two frogs, eat the large one first. Nobody's eating frogs, but the idea is, again, confront it. I'm a piper, I've got to play the bagpipes. I'm not feeling like it right now, but I'm going to do it now, even though I don't feel like it, because that is consistent with the vision I have for myself, and where I want to go in my life with my piping requires me to play. Get on with it.
On my Inner Circle, I do these live Zoom classes almost every week, and everything is indexed. When I send you the recording from today, it'll be on a page on my Inner Circle that you can access even as a non-member, and you'll see what it's like. There's the video, the summary, the questions and answers, the whole transcript, and it's totally searchable. So on my Inner Circle, whatever you're looking for, you get in there and search for it: setting up easy drones, my drones are taking too much air, hemping, strathspeys, the 80/20 blowing cycle, piobaireachd. It's all there, totally indexed, so you can find what you're looking for.
A couple of questions here. Someone wants to know, what should practice time look like? I think that depends on you and where you are, but we talked about some of that: mix it up. This is something you get to do for fun, people! You haven't been drafted into anything. This is a choose-your-own-adventure. If you're starting to feel like, man, I have to do this, I have to do this, stop right there, because the way to reframe that is: I get to do this. I want to do this, I get to do this.
And maybe at a certain point in your life you say, you know what, I'm taking a break, or I'm taking another break, or I'm going to reconsider. Or maybe you don't give in to that feeling right away, and you say, I'm going to go back and find the things I love to do. I love learning new tunes. I love performing. Figure out what it is. You started this thing, and maybe there's a way you can rekindle the little flame that got you inspired in the first place.
We're also social creatures, so maybe you need to connect with somebody. Join my Inner Circle. Join your local pipe band. Find a teacher. Find an online community. I remember six years ago, when everybody was doing Zoom and staying home: Zoom is better than nothing, but being in person is the way to go. Having community. We are social creatures, that's for sure. I mean, imagine a Zoom dog park? No, that wouldn't work. We're mammals, too.
So I've got all these resources on my Inner Circle: classes, videos, a whole curriculum for coming back from a break. Last week I did one of these Zoom classes about your first 100 days as a piper. It's all there. On my Inner Circle you get the Lesson Library, over 800 lessons now, all my tune downloads and sheet music, and all the live classes. And I'll send you a PDF, Coming Back to the Pipes, all based on today. Check out all the cool stuff in my shop, and tons of free stuff. I launched a new version of my website literally 2 hours ago, so it all looks new: the shop is new, there's a new video library page, and free downloadable guides. I hope you'll check it out as soon as you get off the Zoom, and if anything breaks, let me know!
You want to make your bagpipes easy to play. Get going on the practice chanter. Get going on your pipes. Try to do it most days, and see what happens.
Let's take a look in the chat. If you've got a question, now's a good time to pop it in. What advice do you have for those who may be struggling with the desire to keep playing the pipes? Well, that's up to you, but I would say think about why you started in the first place. That's one way to think about it. Or, what is it that's really bugging you about it? If there's something that's really a bummer, maybe you can address those issues. I've heard from people for whom playing in a pipe band was just stressful, or competing was just stressful, or doing gigs was not fun. Well, you don't have to do that. You can choose your own adventure.
Or you might say, I feel like I'm doing it on my own, and I'm struggling here. Well, find a community. Find an online community like my Inner Circle, or find your local community: your local pipe band. Go to the Highland games. Start introducing yourself to people. Look around. Google your town or your city and "pipe band" or "piping society," and see what's out there. Connect with people. We need community, for sure.
A member wants to know, do you have recommended exercises for starting each morning on the practice chanter? I think it's different for different people, but we could pretty easily come up with a list of basics: your basic scales, your G, D and E grace notes individually, and then the GDEs, and going through your doublings. If I had to narrow it down, I would say doublings, GDEs and tachums, and then some of the classic ones you want to hit: birls, D throws, taorluaths, that sort of thing. On my Inner Circle you just click on Exercises, and all my exercises are there, with the recording and a PDF you can download.
A member wants to know, how do you know when a new reed is actually broken in? What you want out of a reed is that it's the right strength for you, and that it has a great sound that is really stable. If it's really hard, that's not going to work. Often what people think of as breaking in a reed is taking a reed that's way too hard and working on it until it's at playing strength. You don't have to do that anymore. The two things that make modern reeds so much better: number one, they're so much more efficient, and they're ready to go right from the manufacturer, meaning you don't have to do a lot of manipulation, scraping, pinching, licking, cutting, all that stuff. They're pretty close.
And the other thing is my Tone Protector. A huge part of what makes a reed sound horrible out of the box, versus once you've played it, is the moisture content in the reed. You order reeds from Ireland or Scotland, and they come in little cardboard boxes wrapped in tissue paper, completely dried out. Or you go to the Highland games or some piping event, and the vendor has those little plastic trays with the reeds sitting there, completely dried out. You have no way of knowing if those reeds are any good. They're certainly not going to be good in that dried-out condition. So you want to get those reeds into the Tone Protector reed case, or into the cap. Once they're in there, you have an idea of what they're actually going to be like. If a huge part of the breaking-in process is just getting the moisture into the reed, then once it's been in the Tone Protector, it's broken in. What you want is a reed that's the right strength and has the right humidity level, and if those two things are right and it's a good reed, it's going to be stable. Boom, you're good to go. No breaking in needed.
A member wants to know, can I revive my old favorite reed from the good old days? I would say maybe. Get it into the Tone Protector, get the moisture back into it, and see what it does. You don't need to throw it out. But if it was a junk reed back then, it's not going to be any better now. Putting some moisture into it will give you an idea of how the reed really is.
Let me pull up one more thing and show you what my Inner Circle looks like when you're logged in. I did a session for my members a couple of days ago, a practice chanter session where we spend an hour answering people's questions. You get a summary, there's the video, and a couple of tune PDFs you can download. I think this is better than YouTube, actually, because it's got all these great summaries. All the questions that were asked by members are answered here, plus the full transcript. Everything is on here.
Let's go to Exercises: all my exercises, the whole Power Series, doublings, GDEs, triplets. It's all there. All my tunes: let's go to Bonnie Dundee. There's a recording of me on the pipes, an audio lesson and sheet music you can download. Also these guides. So what are you interested in? I want to learn about the tachum. There it is. Every time I talk about a tachum, anywhere in 800 different lessons, it's right here, and it zooms right to that part.
This is the thing I'm most excited about since I started BagpipeLessons.com 26 years ago, because every single thing I've taught is here on this website, and it's totally searchable. So if I say I want to learn about motivation: boom, look at all that. I have a whole course, Consistency, Habits and Motivation, out of 7 different courses. It's all here, people, and I would love to have you. Every live session is here too, and you can add them to your Google Calendar. The whole deal.
It's a great time to be a bagpiper, and it's a great time to come back to being a bagpiper, because there are so many great options for equipment: reeds, moisture control, Tone Protectors, microphones, all that good stuff. It's also a great time to get access to information. That's why I created my Inner Circle. Everything you could possibly want is there, and if you're in there and you have a question that isn't covered, I want to hear from you, because I want to make a lesson about it. It's totally interactive, and you get community there too. We get to do these every week, and you can address whatever your pain points and challenges are.
Playing the bagpipes is not a skill; it's many, many different skills. It's many different talents, many different things, and that's what I love about it. And at the end of it, you have something you get to share with the world. You get to go out there and play.
I think we'll wrap it up there. Thanks, everybody. Really great session, and thank you for your questions. If you have a question about anything we talked about today, or if you're watching the replay and something comes up, please email me. This is what I do. I registered BagpipeLessons.com in 1999, back in the old days of the steam-powered internet, and here we are. I wish you the best with the rest of your day and your week. Holidays are coming up: Happy Thanksgiving, Merry Christmas, all that stuff. Look for an email from me today or tomorrow with the replay, and let me know if you have any questions. Thanks, everybody! See you next time. Mahalo.
Lightly cleaned up for reading. Member questions are labeled — no names.
🔴 The Inner Circle
Want a class like this, every week?
Members get a live Zoom class with me every week, plus every replay I have ever recorded — searchable to the exact moment anything was taught. Type easy reed, Tone Protector or 80/20 blowing and you land on the answer. Tunes with sheet music and recordings, topic guides, courses, a community page, and a Q&A page where you can highlight any sentence on the site and ask me about it.
$399/yearBilled yearly — works out to $33.25 a month
$45/monthMonth to month — cancel anytime
Join for the year and we start with a one-on-one goal-setting session with me — on Zoom, or a phone call if you prefer — to get you on the right path.
Already own the Bagpipe Essentials Masterclass? Email me at support@bagpipelessons.com and I will credit the $150 toward your membership. Pipe band? Email me too — the whole-band rate is a big discount.